Reply to What differentiates those non-prodigies who make it to HYPS?

Forum Index » College and University Discussion

Reply to "What differentiates those non-prodigies who make it to HYPS? "

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous]Personally for me, right now an admission nod from Caltech and to a slightly lesser extent from MIT is a much bigger badge of honor and signals a lot more about the academic credentials and "prodigiousness" of the kid than an admit into HYPS.

Caltech and MIT both don't use restrictive admission policies and Caltech specially evaluates candidates primarily on their academic potential, rather than trying to execute on some social engineering obsession. They let the cards fall where they may (so lack of "outward" diversity be damned, with the class being 40%+ Asian), because if the kid is not well prepared for an elite school, they will get their head handed out to them and their self confidence will be completely shattered because of the mismatch problems. But most of the elite schools engaging in holistic admissions just don't care about how many of the students admitted for diversity reasons are forced to switch to less competitive majors because they can't cut it in the super competitive majors. They don't care that it is a disservice to the career prospects of these kids who could have had great careers in the competitive kids if they had been matched to schools based on their abilities. Right now between URM's, first gens, legacies, athletes and others, HYPS is admitting enough kids who are quite mediocre in their capabilities that just knowing that a random kid got into one of these schools signals very little about their "prodigiousness"  On the other hand, if a kid gets into Caltech, you know they are razor sharp.

Don't get me wrong, there are a lot of really smart kids at HYPS. It's just that the signaling affect from these schools is going to continue to diminish as they abandon strict academic standards and use all kinds of dubious criteria couched as "holistic" admissions to admit kids. Then they make things worse through grade inflation and a watered down curriculum. [/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics