Reply to Will Deal challenge a smart kid?

Forum Index » DC Public and Public Charter Schools

Reply to "Will Deal challenge a smart kid?"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]HS counselor here.

OK, so don't believe it. Believe whatever you want. Believe that differentiation in a Deal humanities classroom where some students work below grade level, others at grade level, and others ahead of grade level (possibly 2 or 3 years ahead) provides the best possible preparation for high school for the "smart kids" in the room. If differentiation in the classroom was guaranteed to bring out the best in every advanced MS student living in NW, why would any municipality in the country bother funding and running full-time middle school GT programs? This discussion pertains to challenging "smart kids" at Deal, not average kids.

If you really want an answer to your question, consider attending an open house at the Takoma Park MoCo MS Math/Sci Magnet, or the Eastern MS Humanities Magnet in Silver Spring, or, better yet, the Hunter College MS in NYC (they admit around 6% of 5th grade applicants).  [/quote]

Do you mean that every single student going from Deal to private is behind? I've read the private school board for years and many people have said their kids haven't had a problem transitioning. Does that mean they are delusional? Could you, perhaps, have any biases?

In the same vein, I find it odd that every private offers extensive differentiation. A friend of mine pulled her kid out of a big-3 because the math wasn't challenging - though it was fine for her other kids. So many kids entered in pre-k and/or got sibling preference that it cannot be that every kid there is a super star.

People have narratives they need to back up and use random anecdotes to back it up. I've tried to be helpful - but I don't think answering these really do much. Likely the OP's have their minds made up; they now seek validation. [/quote]

The college counselor poster caveated her statements.

She said that parents she'd worked with who had students coming out of Deal were surprised to find they were behind "[i]magnet school students[/i]" and the "[i]strongest students at top privates[/i]."

So not every suburban public. Not every student at every private.

[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics