Reply to Favorite College that changes lives?

Forum Index » College and University Discussion

Reply to "Favorite College that changes lives? "

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]I wish I could've gotten kid to consider Beloit or Lawrence. They both looked really good on paper. DD met Lawrence rep at a college fair, and said the rep was raving about the music program... "I'm not a music person," DD told me. And for her, that was that.

You know I was looking at Jeff's summary of this thread, (I didn't realize he did that), and it's depressing. The summary is all about our stupid troll and how tiresome we all are. But I think we've been able to exchange some great information. I know I appreciate what I've learned, and this discussion. [/quote]

Amidst all the bashing and bickering, there are some real gold nuggets of information here about the actual schools themselves. I'm not the OP, but this is information I hoped to glean when I read the initial post. I skipped over pages and pages of insults to get to those and found them extremely helpful, so a big thank you to those who shared your thoughts and experiences! There are some very informative, thoughtful, and supportive posts here. For example we weren't considering SLACs in the Pacific Northwest, but now we're inspired to visit, and the information about other CTCLs and schools like them has been extremely helpful. [/quote]

Jeff didn’t say anything about anybody “trolling.”  He just said that the very mention of “CTCL schools” as a group gets folks worked up on both sides.  There’s actually very little bashing of any individual school on this thread other than maybe Evergreen State but that school probably deserves it.  The complaint by the so-called “CTCL haters” is the idea that these schools all somehow belong in a special and exclusive grouping.  They don’t - they are very different from each other in terms of focus, degrees offered, financial health, admissions standards and graduation rates, etc.  The one common feature is that they’re all small and focus on undergraduate teaching - but literally so does the entire US News list of “liberal arts colleges” and there are a couple hundred of them.

[b]Even Jeff sounded somewhat skeptical of the grouping and suggested that it is only of marginal benefit to several of the schools that have established good reputations for themselves entirely independent of being a so-called CTCL school.[/b] [/quote]

Jeff may very well be right and the current CTCL categorization is certainly out of date. Reed and Denison may have moved up out of the CTCL category, and other schools have entered it. Whether the grouping is "only of marginal benefit to several of the schools" is not as important to me as the benefit of the school to my kid. I've found this discussion helpful in trying to find high quality SLACs that will accept, develop, and nurture my DC, who doesn't have a hook and is a B student. Other families appear to be looking at SLACs that are cheaper options for their high-achieving children who are being offered generous merit aid. My family loves the SLAC model with small classes and dedicated teaching professors.  Elite SLACs would not look at my kid, and I know there are excellent regional publics that would work well and more cheaply, but we really want a small school.. I appreciate the exchange of thoughts and impressions here. It has generated some more options that we plan to explore. [/quote]

Me too, and that's what I was hoping for when I started the thread. It was less about "the list" and more as the list as a jumping off point for a certain type of school and student.

We have merit offers from 3 schools on "the list" and another two schools that have also been mentioned. This is really helping me figure out more about them. [/quote]

Congratulations on the merit offers! I've also got some great ideas from this thread, so thank you for starting it. [/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics