Reply to s/o redshirting an advanced girl

Forum Index » Schools and Education General Discussion

Reply to "s/o redshirting an advanced girl"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]Redshirting is for kids who are not academically ready, not for kids who are advanced!! What do you think is going to happen to a bright child if you redshirt her? She is going to be bored out of her mind, which could cause serious problems down the line. Seriously, this is one of the weirder things I have read here: my child should be held back because she is advanced??

[/quote]
My title for the thread I admit, is misleading.  This is not about holding back a child because she is advanced. Being advanced is a symptom of her nature. Driven, not balanced and not interested in creative role playing as much as achievement. Advanced kids become average and vice versa - I get it. However, being well adjusted and balanced will hopefully contribute to good friendships and long term happiness along the way.

I agree with you though. Holding her back in Pre-K may backfire in other ways and be compounded by her need to overachieve in every situation.

I should have asked how to get her to just be a child and calm the f*$k down [/quote]

You have some intense expectations for a four year old! Where is the belief you have that children need to be balanced, interested in role playing, and not driven, coming from? The possible gender implications of this are hard to ignore. Is it because she's not conforming to a girl stereotype of being other-focused and into creative play?  Can you picture saying that a boy was too focused on achievement?

Are you projecting something here? Do you feel you yourself are too driven and missed opportunities to take it easier? Are you seeing yourself in your daughter?

Conversely, are their specific negatives that you are overlooking? Is there some kind of concrete problem with social skills that you need to pay attention to? Focusing on her achievement level isn't going to fix that, if that's the problem.

[/quote]

OP here. I'm not sure where to begin responding but let me say this. I want a balanced life for BOTH my children, with friendships from all walks of life including their age peers, perspective and the ability to buoy the highs and lows life has to offer. If that means having to give up a little advancement or drive in the short run then so be it. I love that my son has that naturally - he is easy going, rebounds quickly from disappointment but is also now at 9 years, pulling far ahead of his peers academically. I would totally be worried if my son was overly focused on achievement.

My daughter is nothing like me, which is why I am here on an anonymous forum trying to make sense of what is going on in her head and how to best shepherd her through so she grows up to be 'my definition' of happy. You are right though. It is my definition of what makes for a fine adult and the qualities I seek in my friends. She is not me and may find happiness her way.

WRT to her social skills, she does need to work on her social interactions with peers. Her closest in age best friends are 9 months older than her and many of the kids she prefers to hang out with are 6-7. They like her, include her in their play. I'm hoping that a play based environment helps with that.

[/quote]

She IS just being a child.  She's just not being the kind of child you think she should be.  As long as you aren't pushing her or pressuring her, and make clear to her that you love her regardless of her accomplishments, and give her opportunities for unstructured play, you're doing what you need to do.  She may just be a more intense kid, and you aren't going to change that by holding her back in school or switching schools or anything else.  You can help by teaching her how to make the best of who she is--strategies for coping with disappointment/not being the very best, ways to moderate a competitive nature when needed for the sake of friendships, etc.  It will be more challenging for you than parenting the son who is more like you, that is for sure.

But you need to learn to accept your daughter for who she is.  It sounds like she's doing well socially--older kids like her and play with her, which suggests that she is not disruptive, knows how to get along and go along with others, etc.  That suggests that she is maybe more socially mature than many of her peers.  As long as she is polite, friendly, and kind to her peers, she's fine.  It's not really a big deal that she likes kids who are slightly older--her peers will catch up soon.  Plus, if she prefers slightly older kids, holding her back so that her classmates are even younger is really not going to help matters.  [/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics