Reply to Why do parents who send their kids to Montessori seem to think their kids are better educated?

Forum Index » Schools and Education General Discussion

Reply to "Why do parents who send their kids to Montessori seem to think their kids are better educated?"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]

Your response is nonsensical.  A mom complained her kid was bored yet also said she wasn't pulled for enrichment.  She can't be that "bored" then, can she?  This is not about my issues.  It is about being tired of hearing too many parents bragging about their kids....most without a true basis for doing so.  Seems like you may have been/are one of those moms... [/quote]

Yet you are the woman who wrote this:

[quote]Things my non-Montessori, play-based preschool attending son could do before K:

--Knew the capital of every state 
--Knew the location of every state (i.e. hand him a blank map and say, "Where is New Hampshire?" and he could point to it) 
--Knew the planets in order 
--Knew how to add and subtract numbers 12 and less 
--Could read fluently (like Frog and Toad type books) 
--Wrote sentences himself (as in, he'd sit down and would write on his own, unprompted: "Pleas do not tch this diaree. It is min" for "Please do not touch this diary. It is mine."

And this is why I CANNOT STAND when parents mention Montessori preschool as being some end all/be all of education. Kids are different. I just sit there with my mouth shut smiling at you "sympathizing" about how unstimulated your "poor" kid is in kindergarten but I'm thinking: STFU. My kid isn't unstimulated and it is hard to envision yours is above mine as far as his/her learning.[/quote]

You seem to think you have a basis for bragging, don't you?  You have a hard time envisioning a child above yours as far as her learning?

You have one child that is barely above grade level, and you think you can speak with authority on the subject of boredom in school?  (And, everything you have listed is about average for mid kindergarten-1st grade, hardly advanced.)  FWIW the smartest kid I met in kindergarten was not reading or doing math.  He was a storyteller and inventor.  He struggled in a rigid environment.  He was truly brilliant.  Scary brilliant. [/quote]

No, I'm not bragging whatsoever.  I'm simply saying that if my kid isn't bored, yours shouldn't be (on the basis of already knowing the material being taught).  If your kid isn't being pulled out, then your kid doesn't know the material as the top tier in the grade does, and your kid shouldn't be 'bored' based on the reasoning that the material is a rehashing of what is already known.   You're clearly one of "those moms" who I'm complaining about...[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics