Reply to MAGA: Harvard tanks to no. 3

Forum Index » Political Discussion

Reply to "MAGA: Harvard tanks to no. 3"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous]Here’s a clearer breakdown of Harvard’s Nobel laureates by the type of affiliation — based on official Harvard lists and typical academic definitions. The categories are:

Alumni — studied at Harvard (undergrad or graduate)

Faculty when prize-winning work was done — actively Harvard teaching/research faculty at the time the Nobel work was done

Former faculty or other temporary roles — once taught or researched at Harvard, but not as the setting for the Nobel work

Other affiliations — visiting positions, short-term researchers, fellows, etc.

I’ll illustrate with actual examples to make each category concrete.

🧬 1. Alumni (Studied at Harvard)

These laureates attended Harvard as students (undergraduate or graduate):

Dudley R. Herschbach – earned AM and PhD at Harvard but did not do his Nobel work while on Harvard faculty (Chemistry, 1986).

Sheldon Glashow – got his PhD at Harvard; Nobel in Physics 1979 (his work wasn’t Harvard faculty research).

David M. Lee – Harvard BA; Nobel in Physics 1996 (work elsewhere).

Interpretation: These count as affiliated alumni, not as Harvard researchers at the time of their Nobel work.

🧪 2. Faculty at the time of Nobel-winning work

These are people who were Harvard faculty researchers actually doing the work recognized by the Nobel Prize:

Gary Ruvkun (Medicine, 2024) — Professor of Genetics at Harvard Medical School when he won.

William G. Kaelin Jr. (Medicine, 2019) — Harvard professor and researcher (Nobel work tied to his lab there).

Claudia Goldin (Economics, 2023) — Henry Lee Professor of Economics at Harvard; Nobel work tied to her long academic career there.

Oliver Hart (Economics, 2016) — Long-time Harvard professor.

Alvin E. Roth (Economics, 2012) — Harvard professor when awarded.

Thomas C. Schelling (Economics, 2005) — Harvard professor when his major work was done.

👉 These are the strongest Harvard associations — the Nobel work was done while they were part of Harvard’s faculty.

📉 3. Former faculty / other roles

This is a looser affiliation — the laureate once taught or held a position at Harvard, but the Nobel work was done elsewhere or after they left:

Victor Ambros (Medicine, 2024) — noted as “formerly at Harvard,” but his Nobel-winning work isn’t tied to Harvard labs.

Amartya Sen (Economics, 1998) — Held an emeritus or earlier role, but much of his Nobel-recognized work was already completed before returning to Harvard.

So Harvard counts them because of prior roles, but their Nobel impact isn’t Harvard-centric.

🌍 4. “Other” / Organizational affiliations

Some Nobel laureates are counted because of non-traditional roles or indirect associations:

Maria Ressa (Peace, 2021) — Was a fellow at Harvard Kennedy School when awarded Nobel Peace Prize (fellowship is a temporary affiliation).

Peace prize organizations linked to Harvard initiatives (e.g., International Physicians for the Prevention of Nuclear War includes Harvard founders).

These are not faculty or alumni in the usual academic sense, but they are counted in broad tallies.

🧠 Summary Table
Affiliation Category	What It Means	Example Laureates
Alumni	Studied at Harvard, Nobel work done elsewhere	Herschbach, Glashow, Lee
Faculty at Nobel work	Research & teaching at Harvard when doing Nobel-winning research	Ruvkun, Kaelin, Goldin, Hart, Roth, Schelling
Former Faculty / Other Roles	Taught or was affiliated earlier; Nobel work not tied to Harvard	Ambros, Sen
Other / Temporary	Visiting fellows, program affiliations at time of award	Maria Ressa, peace org founders
📌 Key Takeaways

✔ Not all “Harvard-affiliated” winners were Harvard professors doing the work there.
✔ Many are alumni, or had brief roles, or were fellows.
✔ Only a subset were active faculty researchers at Harvard performing the Nobel-recognized work.

Harvard’s broad count blends all of the above, which is why their number looks so large — but a more academically meaningful subset are the faculty researchers whose Nobel work was tied to Harvard itself.[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics