Reply to Sienna School vs Field

Forum Index » Private & Independent Schools

Reply to "Sienna School vs Field"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]Maret has a 10% admissions rate for 6th. Where does the next 10% go? Not Sidwell, GDS, or NCS. They go to Field.

It is not a school where Sienna students would thrive. That misconception leads to many students being weeded out during admissions.[/quote]

Kids leaving Siena with remediated dyslexia can thrive in lots of places, including Field (and Maret). When my child was at Field (several years ago), there were a number of kids who had come from Lab after they no longer needed the intensive support.[/quote]

Kids with remediated dyslexia can thrive anywhere. However Field does not offer the remediation.[/quote]

Field is no longer the place it was when Lab School kids successfully went there in high numbers.  It is sad to see Field try to be something it is not, it is not GDS, it is not Gonzaga or Sidwell and it is failing to make the grade. [i][/i][b] Lab School needs a better partner so we are keeping our eyes on Sienna, I hope they stay true to their mission better than Field[/b].[/quote]

I think of Siena as equivalent to Lab, not a next step. Whereas pre-pandemic, Field was proud of accepting kids with disabilities -- not as a SN school, but a place that was accommodating and inclusive to those who no longer needed specialized instruction. While the new attitude toward disabilities might serve some students fine, it's a loss to the private school universe.[/quote]

Field has long been a magnet for parents of special needs kids because it lets parents feel like they have mainstreamed their child in an expensive private school that has some of the bells and whistles of other independent schools---but little to no homework or academic challenge.  Field has been desperate for money over the many years since it built out its current campus and has been happy to admit anyone who can pay. But the problem for the kids is that Field has minimal capacity to meet the needs of special needs kids.  [b]So those kids languish, get distracted and disruptive,  and drag down the entire class.  [/b]That's the modern Field story.  Old timers there will talk about the vision of the founder and of everyone sitting around some broken down mansions in Kalorama counting on an abacus and singing Kumbaya. But those days are long gone and the new Field business plan is to grab as much money as it can by admitting rich kids with significant needs who have parents with too much pride to enroll them in a school actually set up to help them.

[/quote]

Ok, that's just offensive. I'm no fan of Field -- I posted upthread that we are one of the families to which Field promised a lot and delivered little. They were not able to support my autistic child and we left. But while we were there, my child was not disruptive and did not "pull down the class." No one suffered from her presence except her. I promise you that autism and learning disabilities are not contagious.[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics