Reply to Moving from Arlington to Bethesda(ish) for job--best school clusters?

Forum Index » Montgomery County Public Schools (MCPS)

Reply to "Moving from Arlington to Bethesda(ish) for job--best school clusters?"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]

True. And some may have [b]more[/b].  My student is motivated by being in classes filled with others who are too.  Make sure you are in a cluster where this is the case.

[/quote]

I don't know what to say to people who believe that only [i]some[/i] of the high schools in MCPS have a cohort of academically-motivated students.[/quote]

No one is saying that, including the PP you responded to.  Some people are saying that there is a difference in the size of the cohort of academically motivated kids and also that there can be degrees of academic motivation.
[/quote]

Plenty of people say that, including the PP(s) above.[/quote]

What do you think "more" means?  I even emboldened it for you in my last post to stand out.

It is clear (and would have been more so if you hadn't cut off the thread midpoint) that PP was saying that some schools have [i]more[/i] or a [i]larger[/i] academically motivated cohort than others.  No one has said only "some" schools have this.

This size of this cohort may or may not matter to you, and that's fine, but let's not create straw men of what others are posting.[/quote]

DP, and I don't think anyone's claiming there aren't differences in the size of the college-bound cohorts between MCPS high schools.  The data make that clear.

What I (and I suspect others) object to is the claim that non-W school high school kids can't possibly compete intellectually with their W-school peers.  In my own little corner of the DCC, you can't walk a block without finding a parent, and usually more than one, with a Ph.D. (tons of academics and government scientists here, along with teachers, social workers, police officers, stay at home parents, etc., although very few BigLawyers/lobbyists/consultants).  [b]It's both ignorant and insulting to suggest that our kids are intellectually inferior to those in the W schools, and, yes, that's exactly what PPs who claim that AP/IB classes in the DCC aren't "at the same level" as W schools are saying[/b].  In providing advice to someone who is looking to move into the area, and doesn't know much about the distinctions between schools, it's important to be honest about what you do and don't know.[/quote]

No one is saying that any individual kid is or is not at the same level.  There are absolutely are kids in the DCC (or any other school) that are very bit as smart as kids at a W school.  But, the fact that there is a smaller cohort of college-bound kids (and a smaller cohort aiming for competitive colleges) does change the dynamic, in the classroom and more broadly.  But, let's stop talking in the abstract.  Let's look at data.

https://www.montgomeryschoolsmd.org/departments/sharedaccountability/reports/2019/2018%20AP%20and%20IB%20Course%20Enrollment%20and%20Exam%20Participation%20and%20Performance.pdf

Appendix B above shows the percentage of kids scoring 3 or higher on AP, which ranges from 91% at Wooton to 35.1% at Watkins Mill.

So, yes, a student taking AP X at Wooton or Watkins Mill is being taught the same curriculum, but do you really not believe there will be a difference in terms of what the class can cover and the depth of discussions that will occur?  Obviously, those are the extremes, but if you look at the data there is a pronounced difference among high schools, with lots of schools in the 80s and others in the 30s or 50s (oddly none in the 40s).  Of course, this only looks at AP classes.  Almost no students (none if you count things like gym and electives) will be in all AP classes and the student body as a whole becomes more relevant there as well.

Again, this isn't to say that there aren't kids at Watkins Mill (or elsewhere) every bit as smart and smarter than kids at Wooton or that a kid can't get a good education at any MCPS school, but [b]I think it is wrong to say that, just because there is a college-bound cohort at all MCPS schools, there differences between schools are irrelevant to someone's high school education and experience.[/b]

[/quote]

It is wrong to say that, because of course it's not true.  It's also not what I said.  Moreover, believe it or not, some parents actually value diversity in the school setting, to the point where having a smaller college-bound cohort and perhaps less intellectually fervent discussions in AP English is less important than learning to get along with people from all walks of life and being aware that there are other walks of life, period.

But really, what horrible outcome is going to befall a bright, motivated kid who has a smaller cohort of similar peers in high school?  I'm honestly curious to know what people are trying to avoid (or promote).  [/quote]

I hope you didn't hurt your back moving the goal posts or building straw men.  I didn't say that any "horrible outcome" would befall a student at such schools.  In fact, I explicitly said a kid can "get a good education at any MCPS school."

To the extent that you value things other than academics at a school and you believe that certain schools excel in those areas, that's great.  You should go with what you prioritize.  We were, however, discussing the academic component.[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics