Reply to “Amy Bradley is Missing” Netflix

Forum Index » Entertainment and Pop Culture

Reply to "“Amy Bradley is Missing” Netflix"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]Cigarettes and lighter and room key were gone. Could be that all were in her pockets, but I know I generally set the key down on a table once I've entered. The small detail of the balcony door being partially open (when her dad initially saw it closed) suggests to me that she left the room again and that the ~6AM sighting with Yellow was accurate. That doesn't mean I think Yellow did anything to her, more likely she left the ship for whatever reason then got into trouble.[/quote]
A smoker wouldn't pick up the cigarettes and put them in their pocket to jump, she would have left them for her brother. [/quote]

3 separate witnesses saw Amy with Yellow after she left the balcony. Unlikely they're all wrong.[/quote]

There’s no way to actually confirm the timeline that night/morning. There’s a lot of room for speculation.

I just think it’s odd that anyone would stay up all night and then wander out again at dawn…barefoot.

Ships are big. It’s unlikely that the two had prearranged a rendezvous and even more unlikely they randomly ran into each other around that timeframe when all the bars and clubs had shut down.

Plus, she was a lesbian. It would be very odd for a lesbian to pursue a man. Unless she was a party girl or addict feening for drugs…but her family would have had some visibility on that and would have shared that information to frame the most likely scenario. But, you would also imagine that her family would have kept a closer eye on her if she was a party girl/addict. (Btdt with my party girl sister. No way anyone would have left my sister drunk at a club.)[/quote]

Except she apparently was a party girl. Her dad went to drag her back to the cabin at 3am (in itself pretty crazy) then no indication she planned to go to bed.[/quote]
All of her college friends talked about her partying and never mentioned drugs though. I agree with the PPs who think a dark thirty drug buy on an unfamiliar island doesn’t sound in character for her at all although it checks some of the other boxes that would explain why she first went missing.[/quote]

I’m the same age and I drank a TON in college but never did drugs and didn’t know any women that did  It just wasn’t that common for college education women at that time.  I don’t think it’s an all likely that she went to go score drugs in the middle of the night or off the boat.  Falling off the ship makes a lot more sense but I agree that it doesn’t really fit with the two women who saw her and the fact that the trafficked woman looks so much like her.  [/quote]
PP you’re responding to and I’m the exact same - only a year or so older than Amy, drank a LOT in college but hardly any weed (although it was around) and no coke (supposedly it was around but I never saw it.) I think what I expected from the documentary is for after the part with the speculation about the early morning drug buy, for it to flip back to interviews with all of her friends saying “that’s ridiculous, I never saw or heard of her doing any kind of drugs” and that didn’t happen.

For those that think the family is somehow involved with her disappearance, I can’t imagine that they would still be pushing this story out there after all of these years if there was any way that the truth would backfire on them. [/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics