Reply to Data today 7pm

Forum Index » Montgomery County Public Schools (MCPS)

Reply to "Data today 7pm"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]When covid first appeared someone used an image of water lilies in a pond multiplying to visualize exponential growth. I am a visual person. That image worked to me. A few cases here and there, no big deal. But as they beget more, suddenly the lake is full. The point here is, things are normal *now.* They may not stay that way.

Or, they may, for your child and your family.

But the real cost of that lies beneath the water, in places you can't see. It lies with people you don't know, will never know. [b]The price of your child's normalcy is surging case rates, hospitals being overwhelmed, and thousands saddled with long-term suffering[/b]. I can't make you believe those people are real. That is something perhaps your own parents, or religion, or conscience should have done long ago.

We all weigh acceptable risk for ourselves and others every day we get in a car, so don't use that old chestnut as a comparison. Covid isn't driving, and omicron isn't delta. When infection rates were much lower our county was doing a good job, even with a lot of people resuming "normal" life. Now, we seem firmly committed to winnowing out the weak, the infirm, the old... Those who should take on the "responsibility" for saving themselves, apparently, even when we don't have the tools for them to do that. And all so Larla's mental health isn't impacted by not being able to run for student body president.

Despite all the purple prose above, I'm not actually a virtual forever person. I am a person who weighs risk to my family and others and makes choices accordingly. At the moment, cases are climbing exponentially at our schools. Based on the examples of other cities (namely New York) we will be where they are soon enough. I don't see the point in putting my kid into that infection chain. It's mostly a matter of conscience, not risk. And I know that seems nuts. Perhaps it is. But I was raised to follow my conscience, even when it tells me what the majority are doing isn't right, and I've tried to live that way through this virus.  Do no harm, is, I think, sometimes the best we can do. [/quote]

Closing schools will do nothing to change anything bolded. It just won't. I understand the desire to *do something,* but I don't understand how anyone still thinks that closing schools will control COVID. It won't. Some of the elderly and disabled will still die, hospitals will face the same burden as if schools were open. All closing schools does is stoke your feeling of moral superiority and the costs are much higher than "not getting to run for class president." [/quote]

Are you denying Covid is spreading in schools? Our child's friend just caught it after being exposed at school both kids masked & vaccinated.  The kids will be fine but what happens to the grandparent who lives in the same house. Having virtual school would have prevented this from happening, multiplying this scenario by hundreds.[/quote]

I'm denying that closing schools changes the COVID numbers at a country level, yes. That's what's is and should be driving policy. A single kid catching COVID somewhere, possibly at school, doesn't change my mind on that. COVID infections are going to run rampant for the next couple weeks. That'll be true if we close schools or not.[/quote]

So you're saying that the grandparent is just collateral damage? Or that it's only one grandparent? Or that the family doesn't have the right to have a safe option for educating their kid? You're saying that all multigenerational families in the county have to undergo a winnowing because, although we have the technology for them to attend school safely, you think it's too complicated to do that for a few weeks until the surge subsides?

If, as you say, COVID needs to burn through our county, don't we all have a collective obligation to protect the vulnerable while that's happening? [/quote]

No, MCPS should absolutely not be going district-wide virtual. If a household feels in-person is unsafe given their circumstances, they should make alternative arrangements.[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics