Reply to Zohran Mamdani...

Forum Index » Political Discussion

Reply to "Zohran Mamdani..."

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]I think what this primary demonstrates is that the [b]working and middle class - the majority of Americans - are completely up for grabs for both parties.[/b] The GOP is all in with the oligarchs and Christian conservatives. Democrats have been all in with progressives - LatinX, Terfs, Trans, CIS whatever, DEI, ACAB, Gaza, masks, and so on.

Normal people reject both. And the party that reaches people on everyday issues - health care, inflation, housing/rent, safe schools, the environment, enormous income disparities, corrupt politicians, and even food deserts - is the party that wins. It seems that Mamdani is hitting that space - really focused on everyday issues for people in NYC that aren't earning seven figures. I do think if the AOC/Sanders part of the Democratic party really focuses on kitchen table issues, they'll do very well nationally.

But if they get lost in the social issues that progressives are all about, Democrats will continue to lose. I get that the NYPD has its issues. But if Mamdani is going to neuter them with "violence interruptors" and "social workers" that lead to an increase in violent crime, it kills Democrats nationally. NYC is a big stage. If Mamdani get this wrong, it'll have national repercussions. [/quote]

The working class and certainly the lower class most definitely did not vote for this socialist in a majority.  At all. 
He won the election with white liberal elites:

Yes, the mayoral hopeful’s campaign has masterfully mobilized an energetic base. But the “unprecedented coalition” in question are not made up of the paycheck-to-paycheck New Yorkers that he wants us to believe.

The electoral map doesn’t just fail to reflect his working-class coalition – it flips it. It shows a victory carried by the very neighborhoods his story skips over.

New Yorkers in areas where the median income is above $117,600 backed Mr. Mamdani by 13 points. Middle-income precincts followed right behind. Lower-income New Yorkers? They broke just as hard for Cuomo instead.

Whiter, wealthier, more ideologically driven New Yorkers are certainly overrepresented in this primary. Take Flatbush and East Flatbush – two neighborhoods situated together with comparable populations. Gentrified Flatbush opted for Mamdani by 16 points, versus the Caribbean-dominated East Flatbush, which preferred Cuomo by 37 points.

The difference? About 5,000 more Flatbush voters participated in the primary. Mr. Mamdani’s win simply reflects a truism about primaries: Affluent ideologues appear in droves until the general election resets the balance.

When I broke down Mamdani’s donor base by ZIP code using NYC Campaign Finance Board data, I found his campaign is no exception.

The same affluent ZIP codes with the highest large-dollar donor participation significantly overlap with those driving Mamdani’s “grassroots” small donor base – the very donors he claims represent the city’s working class.

https://www.news-journal.com/zohran-mamdani-working-class-mayor-for-upper-class-voters/article_4f37464b-557d-5720-825e-723fe6bb22c8.html
[/quote]

“How New Yorkers voted: Mr. Mamdani’s success was built on a novel coalition of young, progressive, Latino and South Asian voters rooted in Manhattan, Brooklyn and Queens.”

https://www.nytimes.com/live/2025/06/25/nyregion/zohran-mamdani-nyc-mayor-election

He activated young progressives, which is something that the current crop of near republican democrats fail to do.
[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics