Reply to I'm a Muslim. Ask me anything!

Forum Index » Religion

Reply to "I'm a Muslim. Ask me anything!"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]
The disgruntled part is the part you should focus on. You are on a one woman vendetta, a campaign against Islam and Muslims. [b]I quoted to you passages from Leila Ahmeds book where she praises Islam and I'm sure you were befuddled. [/b]I have a few more scholarly books written by various other nonMuslim scholars to quote from that confirm Leila Ahmed's assertions. I think you are so hateful toward Islam because of your own negative personal experience that you have lost all ability to reason, be fair, or just. The greatest outcome of your hate has been a flurry of interested reporters and investigative journalists who now want to research your posts. I never expected that, but it brings me solace to know that something good may come out of this.[/quote]

Not the PP you're calling "befuddled." I posted on the Micro-aggressions thread about how you're trying to change the subject and blame it on innocent Dr. Ahmed. You ignored me and so I reposted. Here's another repost, and maybe you'll read it this time.
[b]
Your debate with the other PP was about whether pre-Islamic Arabia was good or bad for women, and whether Islam was better or worse for women than pre-Islamic Arabia. [/b]But you clearly don't want to talk about pre-Islamic Arabia. I can understand why, because Dr. Ahmed is pretty ambivalent about that. Instead, you'd much rather talk about Dr. Ahmed's opinions of Islam *today* and her theory of ethical equality and criticism of establishment Islam, both of which she does indeed discuss at the end of her book.

[b]You're trying to switch subjects on that PP you're arguing with. [/b]And you're trying to do this by exploiting the natural historic progression in Dr. Ahmed's book -- from pre-Islamic Arabia at the start of her book to modern Islam at the end of her book. Does everybody see how that works?

[b]The worst part of your behavior is how you blame Dr. Ahmed for your own effort to switch subjects [/b]from pre-Islamic Arabia to modern Islam. That's right. Dr. Ahmed traveled 1400 years forward in history. You're  trying to label this an "evolution of opinion" and "writing something different in the beginning of the book" in your effort to suggest that she changed her mind about pre-Islamic Arabia. She most definitely did not change her mind about pre-Islamic Arabia. It's obvious what you're doing here.[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics