Reply to I'm a Muslim. Ask me anything!

Forum Index » Religion

Reply to "I'm a Muslim. Ask me anything!"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]Umm, didn't you address your post directly to me? Thats why I read it. [/quote]

Again - why are you complaining about reading stuff no one forced you to read?

[quote=Anonymous]First of all, I think I have said quite clearly I do not know about that immigrant poster's previous posts. I would have to view them all to see his position on other kinds of Muslims to determine if he committed takfir. [/quote]
You respond to posts without knowing them? I copied your response to the post calling Shias non-Muslims.

[quote=Anonymous]
 Difference of opinion or criticism is permitted in Islam. Tafkir is quite a different story. Don't mistake one for the other. Therefore, he is not a "takfiri" let alone my "buddy." [/quote]
When someone calls a Muslim a non-Muslim, is it criticism or takfir?

[quote=Anonymous]
Moreover, I did not "pour wrath on nonMuslims"; I corrected your outright lies and misinterpretations of Islamic history and Muhammads relegations. You have to know if you publish false statements about Islam, somebody at some point is going to correct you.[/quote]
You didn't. You tried. But you failed.

[quote=Anonymous]Oh my. More evidence you are an immigrant yourself, most likely a disgruntled Pakistani of a minority faith who wants to spread hate about Islam. "Kool Aid" is not spelled "Cool-Aid." It's a typical idiomatic expression that you are clearly unfamiliar with because you can't spell it! Your posts are quite revealing. [/quote]
There is no shame in spelling mistakes, or in being a Pakistani (you little bigot you), for that matter.  Everyone makes spelling mistakes. You've just typed "Muhammad's relegations" two lines above. Did you mean "relegations"? Or "revelations"?  Do you see me making a stink about it? And since you're getting all picky about spelling, it is my pleasure to share with you the correct spelling that is "IslamOphobe", not "IslamAphobe", as you prefer to write it.    And what about your maths refresher? What is greater - 25 thousand or a hundred thousand?

[quote=Anonymous] Worship of the Al-Saud? No, not really. They are not the guardians of the Islamic faith. However, they are the guardians of Kaba, a place of importance to Muslims worldwide. They do decide who may enter Mecca and who may not. You said the immigrant poster (and I) were "takfiri buddies" for rejecting Shia as Muslims and therefore I, in particular, worship Al-Saud. You are drawing a correlation between Saudi Arabia and those accusing nonSunni or nonwahabi as takfiri, particularly Shia people. I clearly showed you that by admitting Shias in Mecca, the government of Saudi Arabia admits they are indeed Muslim. [/quote]

The hatred and sectarianism of Al-Saud is well known.  Letting people into Mecca is not the end-all be-all of Muslimness.  Al-Saud spreads hate about all non-Wahhabi Muslims in the writings it disseminates worldwide, in their schoolbooks used by many Islamic schools worldwide, and through their discriminatory, bigoted policies toward non-Wahhabi Muslims within the country.

[quote=Anonymous]
If a Muslim on any thread does not like what people of another sect are doing, it is their prerogative to criticize it. Shia Muslims do engage in behavior that may be antithetical to islamic principles, but that does not make them nonMuslim.[/quote]

I'm gonna give you a crash course on what is criticism and what is takfir.

"Shias are bad Muslims." = criticism

"Shias are non-Muslims." = takfir

All better now?[/quote]

I did not say I did not know what takfir is; I said I did not see the immigrant poster's posts to agree with you that he committed this sin. You can dismiss it as a petty spelling error, but it is not. I generally do not pay attention to misspellings. This was no misspelling, it was a revelation that shed light on your identity and supports my theory that you are an angry Pakistani out for revenge against Muslims. You don't know much about that expression.  Word of advice, don't use expressions to try to sound "cool" or American if you can't use them properly. :) You had no issue mocking the immigrant poster for speaking poor English...if you dish it out, you better be able to take it.

[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics