Reply to Redshirting August boy?

Forum Index » Private & Independent Schools

Reply to "Redshirting August boy? "

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]The thing that really gets to me are the parents who come on here and post, "Why do you care if I redshirt my kid?! What does it matter to you if I didn't want him to be the youngest?" It matters to me because holding back normally developing summer birthday kids puts non-redshirted kids at a disadvantage. Now, instead of being one year younger than the older peers, they are sometimes 15 months younger than the others. Redshirting skews the age, abilities, maturity, and social capacities of a class. I wish schools would set a cut off and hold to it.[/quote]

But uh, you could also redshirt? Our child’s school effectively requires young boys to redshirt[/quote]

+1 in our 6 years of private school, my redshirted late august birthday girl has never been the oldest in the class and the youngest kid in any of her class was 11 months younger (to the day). My DD did not pu anyone at a disadvantage anymore than September/October kids do.[/quote]

She absolutely did put others at a disadvantage. The whole class gets shifted and the disadvantage goes to the kids with the May and April birthdays (and any summer kids whose parents insist on not redshirting). Please face reality, your kid did benefit but at the expense of others.[/quote]

No, this portion of the debate began from the statement above where a parent claims that redshirting their summer birthday kid did not put "anyone at a disadvantage anymore than a September/October kids" and I was correcting this misstatement. It shifts the disadvantage to the Apr/May kids. It is what it is, but this is fact.[/quote]

That there is a disadvantage is not a fact. No matter how many times you repeat it.[/quote]

It is definitely a fact in that PP’s head. Just not in any actual reality. [/quote]

And of course their is a disadvantage... the redshirted kids benefit from an entire year of development. Physical, emotional, intellectual. Please.[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics