Reply to I'm a Muslim. Ask me anything!

Forum Index » Religion

Reply to "I'm a Muslim. Ask me anything!"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]
I am sorry, but your writing is not easy to absorb. It's the sesquipedalian loquaciousness that gives me a headache at times. It's pretentiousness disguised as intelligence. [/quote]
Is someone holding a gun to your head to read it?

[b]Umm, didn't you address your post directly to me? Thats why I read it.
[/b]

[quote=Anonymous]
Think this through: did you ever consider that maybe I had not read all of immigrant pp's posts?
Secondly, criticism is permitted in Islam. Takfir goes well beyond criticism. I would have to see his posts to determine if he committed it.
Third, where did you get the idea I refrain from criticizing any Muslim, simply because they are Muslim? [/quote]
Because you poured your wrath on non-Muslims who dared to criticize your statements about Islam, but said not a word to your takfiri buddies.
[quote=Anonymous]

[b]First of all, I think I have said quite clearly I do not know about that immigrant poster's previous posts. I would have to view them all to see his position on other kinds of Muslims to determine if he committed takfir. Difference of opinion or criticism is permitted in Islam. Tafkir is quite a different story. Don't mistake one for the other. Therefore, he is not a "takfiri" let alone my "buddy." Moreover, I did not "pour wrath on nonMuslims"; I corrected your outright lies and misinterpretations of Islamic history and Muhammads relegations. You have to know if you publish false statements about Islam, somebody at some point is going to correct you.
[/b]

Lastly, I have never lived in Saudi Arabia and was not born there. Another false assumption. [/quote]
You don't need to live there to drink their Cool-Aid or read the religious studies bullshit they disseminate worldwide
[quote=Anonymous]

[b]Oh my. More evidence you are an immigrant yourself, most likely a disgruntled Pakistani of a minority faith who wants to spread hate about Islam. "Kool Aid" is not spelled "Cool-Aid." It's a typical idiomatic expression that you are clearly unfamiliar with because you can't spell it! Your posts are quite revealing. 
[/b]

One more thing, where did you get the idea I do not accept Shia as Muslims? Shia are permitted to do Hajj in Mecca by the Saudi government. As such it follows that the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia accepts shia as Muslim.

You are trying to create hatred, divisiveness, and controversy. If that wasn't bad enough, your writing...sigh..please...stop.

[/quote]
I have no idea what you do and do not accept.  I laugh at your suggestion that the opinion of the kingdom of Saudi Arabia as to who is and is not a real Muslim means anything.  You have a very bad case of the Al-Saud worship.  Who the hell appointed Al-Saud in charge of deciding who is and is not a real Muslim?

[b]Worship of the Al-Saud? No, not really. They are not the guardians of the Islamic faith. However, they are the guardians of Kaba, a place of importance to Muslims worldwide. They do decide who may enter Mecca and who may not. You said the immigrant poster (and I) were "takfiri buddies" for rejecting Shia as Muslims and therefore I, in particular, worship Al-Saud. You are drawing a correlation between Saudi Arabia and those accusing nonSunni or nonwahabi as takfiri, particularly Shia people. I clearly showed you that by admitting Shias in Mecca, the government of Saudi Arabia admits they are indeed Muslim. [/b]

As for who is creating hatred, divisiveness and controversy, perhaps it's time for you to point your finger to t posters who called the Shia non-Muslims and the Sufis not deserving of trust.  And yet you haven't said a single word to them, not even a mild reprimand that calling Shia non-Muslims is not right. I wonder why that is?[/quote]

If a Muslim on any thread does not like what people of another sect are doing, it is their prerogative to criticize it. Shia Muslims do engage in behavior that may be antithetical to islamic principles, but that does not make them nonMuslim.[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics