Reply to I'm a Muslim. Ask me anything!

Forum Index » Religion

Reply to "I'm a Muslim. Ask me anything!"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]Have you seen All-American Muslim? What did you think of it?  I started watching it after all the right-wing hoopla claiming that the show's producers were avoiding showing militant Muslims.  The issues the show dealt with made sense to me based on what I know from Muslim friends and acquaintances.  I was sorry the show wasn't renewed.

Folks who want to know more about one segment of the Muslim community in the US may want to check it out.  [/quote]

That show was nonsense, the families they showed were [b]shia, aka non-Muslim[/b]s, its a completely different faith! They had tattoos, the women weren't covering all the time, a few were wrapped up in haram (forbidden) money making (The club) and the list goes on and on. It was an extremely poor representation of what a real american Muslim is. Now don't get me wrong they had some key points and very real life situations that everyone goes through, but I'm glad they didn't renew it.[/quote]
Oh you didn't see that, did you.  You did, actually, as you posted a very mild response to that comment upthread.  A more likely answer is that you are reluctant to criticize anyone who might be Muslim.  So here you have your little Wahhabi buddy, pronouncing takfir on a good chunk of the world's Muslims, which is a very great sin in Islam, and it's kind of funny how you found not a single stern word for that poster.   Might that be because you both come from an Al-Saud-funded, Bin-Baz-trained, Shia-hating, vicious strain of belief?

The person who called your pet Hamza Yusuf a not-to-be-trusted Sufi is one of the last posters on the thread about reform. Still waiting for you to upbraid him or her with a modicum of passion you reserve for the kuffar who have the gall to challenge your platitudes. [/quote]

I am sorry, but your writing is not easy to absorb. It's the sesquipedalian loquaciousness that gives me a headache at times. It's pretentiousness disguised as intelligence.

Think this through: did you ever consider that maybe I had not read all of immigrant pp's posts?
Secondly, criticism is permitted in Islam. Takfir goes well beyond criticism. I would have to see his posts to determine if he committed it.
Third, where did you get the idea I refrain from criticizing any Muslim, simply because they are Muslim?

Lastly, I have never lived in Saudi Arabia and was not born there. Another false assumption.

One more thing, where did you get the idea I do not accept Shia as Muslims? Shia are permitted to do Hajj in Mecca by the Saudi government. As such it follows that the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia accepts shia as Muslim.

You are trying to create hatred, divisiveness, and controversy. If that wasn't bad enough, your writing...sigh..please...stop.

[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics