Reply to MCPS practice of not assigning K students a teacher until today? (Poll)

Forum Index » Montgomery County Public Schools (MCPS)

Reply to "MCPS practice of not assigning K students a teacher until today? (Poll)"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]Have a MoCo K'er this year who is going through this.  My $0.02:
-fwiw this is our oldest child so I do not have experience with the "meet the kids during the May orientation, snap judgement, hope for the best" model.
-DC has been in center based daycare/preschool/pre-K for 5 years, with all activities being done in one room per age group (ie the 4YO preschool class learned, ate, played, napped all in the same room).
-the way it was explained to us, 45 mins during orientation the May before K, is not nearly enough time (nor is it the right time) to get to know all these kids and their abilities, etc.  Other schools have (we were told) implemented this draft model with great success... ie leads to an overall better K experience because the classrooms are more balanced.
-DC has a "homeroom" teacher this week... first thing in the AM, last thing in the PM, and spent all day with them on Monday.  They rotate through the other teachers one/day, and stay together as a class.  Tomorrow, the teachers basically do a draft and the kids are given their permanent assigned teacher, report there on Tues, no more rotations.
-they mentioned that they want classes balanced by race and gender, but also ability (so that there's not a lone kid in the class, way ahead or behind).  The intention does not seem to be creating classes segregated by ability, but rather balanced abilities across all classrooms (so not a "smart class" and a "not smart class").
-There has been A LOT of communication around it, so absolutely no confusion on our part.
-DC has reported back on two days of rotation (plus the first day of no-rotation) and did not seem bothered AT ALL.  The kids stay together as a class, and she actually remembered a few of the teachers from open house ("she's the purple lady").  Also, for the first time ever she is also rotating through different rooms... cafeteria, computer room, classroom... so the teacher rota is just another "difference" from preschool.
-I anticipate that on Tuesday we'll have to remind her a couple of times that she now goes to Ms Whoever's class.  But the school seems really on top of that and has said that teachers and aides will continue to be posted in the halls for before/after, etc.
-understand that this is not widely done, but seems likely to become more widespread practice at least in MoCo.  Ask me again at Christmastime, I guess.[/quote]

Interesting perspective.  I'd like to hear other parents post on this!

I have a DD in K this year at a school that is doing this.  However, DD has 2 older siblings, so she is aware of how they do things.  Both older siblings were 'assigned' teachers, and she was a little bummed about that not being the case.

I'll say that with my two older kids, both of them got to know ALL of the teachers anyway throughout the year.  They go to the other teacher's classrooms for parties, etc and by the end of the year (even with my first kid), all the teachers seemed to know her by name.

Our ES did not assign classrooms until today (Thursday), so there were 3 full days of uncertainty.  Honestly, it's a long time for a 5 year old.  She had a few girls in her 'class' the first few days who she became friendly with, who are not still in her class.  Tough deal for a 5 year old girl.

I also doubt that they can determine 'problem kids' within one day, which is what it sounds like your ES did?  How is that so much different than the few hours at orientation?

I don't like it, but agree that maybe I'll feel differently mid-year.[/quote]

I'd like to add that having read the other posts, and comments about 'problem kids', I don't see how this solves that issue.  I'm not a teacher, but with two older kids, I can understand completely how having several tough kids in a class make it a terrible environment for the other kids.  We've dealt with that over the years, for sure.

[b]But, sometimes it's the combination of two kids together that leads to problems.  And, some years, a kid may be a 'problem kid', whereas the next year, with a different teacher, the kid is fine.  [/b]

After two days of rotating around, do the schools that do this find that there are less behavior issues during the year?  Wonder if there are any studies on this.  [/quote]

I think that's the idea. Remove any known issues. Of course KG class lists don't define 1st grade ones. Kids are resorted with input from teachers.

[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics