Reply to satire or hate speech?

Forum Index » Political Discussion

Reply to "satire or hate speech?"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Muslima][quote=Anonymous][quote=Muslima][quote=Anonymous][quote=Muslima]Free speech is not absolute![/quote]

Says who?  You?[/quote]

Freedom of speech is not absolute. The mere fact that there are slander and libel laws is a testament to this. The press is not free to publish the plans for a nuclear bomb. Edward Snowden, Bradley Manning, Wikileaks ring a bell?  The US government has been allowed to limit speech for many, many reasons, because the Supreme Court has recognised that in some cases the harm speech causes can outweigh its value for freedom of speech purposes.[/quote]

Is there a national security or commercial interest inherent in curbing offensive speech?  Who decides what is offensive?  If we rule by law that no one be allowed to say anything that offends anyone else, then no one will be allowed to say anything.  That is the ABSOLUTE antithesis of freedom.  Is that what you want?  It is not what Americans want.  I loathe Westboro Baptist Church with the heat of a thousand suns, but I will defend their right to say what they want.  The same laws that protect them protect those who mobilize to speak against them and physically block out their hate at the funerals they picket.  It's called a war of ideas for a reason.  You don't fight words with guns, and the solution is not to muzzle the population en masse.  I assume you are enjoying your freedom to speak your mind on this forum.  Why would you deny that to someone else?  Are your beliefs so fragile that they can be harmed by words?  Mine are not.[/quote]

Where did I say that I was against freedom of Speech? I stated that regardless of what has been said since the Paris attack, freedom of speech is not absolute, there are many times when states choose security over freedom. On the Charlie Hebdo controversy, I will refer you to what Omar Suleiman said. I am not Charlie Hebdo, nor am I a terrorist.On one hand, I have never insulted anyones religion, prophet, or holy book nor do I approve of others doing so. I do not believe free speech should be used as a cover to insult the most beloved human being to me that's ever lived or any prophet or holy figure. I do not approve of the vile racist cartoons drawn by Charlie Hedbo or any magazine . And if that means I'm not a "moderate Muslim" according to the bigot Bill Maher, then so be it. On the other hand, I believe in principle and value life. I do not sanction vigilantes murdering people indiscriminately. I believe in responding to these evil insults against my Prophet (peace be upon him) with education and mercy. I have seen Arnoud Van Doorn change his life and say "I am sorry oh Prophet of God" and that is far more beloved to me than if someone would've murdered him 2 years ago. I am not Charlie, nor am I a terrorist. I am a follower of the man who was sent as a mercy to the worlds.[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics