Reply to School discipline is back and Mink and Jwando are upset.

Forum Index » Montgomery County Public Schools (MCPS)

Reply to "School discipline is back and Mink and Jwando are upset."

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous]Reading material for those who insist there aren't well-documented racial disparities for lower-level, subjective suspension categories:

SOURCE: https://hechingerreport.org/disobedience-discipline-and-racial-disparity/

[QUOTE]
In Ohio, Black students like Marquan are suspended for incidents like this far more frequently than their white peers. In the past six years, Ohio has issued close to 885,000  suspensions and expulsions for [b]comments and misbehaviors tagged as disobedience or disruption[/b]. Nearly half of those dismissals have been for Black students, even though they make up only 17 percent of the public school population. Black students in Ohio are, on average, kicked out of classes for these offenses at [b]four and half times the rate of white students[/b].

A Hechinger Report analysis across 20 states found that these types of categories are cited as justification in nearly a third of all suspension and expulsion records. [b]In many states, including Indiana, Maryland and Rhode Island, Black students are suspended more often for these kinds of incidents, which can include dress code violations, talking back to teachers and being too noisy in class[/b].

States use different terms to describe the offenses – disrespect, insubordination, defiance – depending on their discipline code. But what they all have in common is the subjective nature of an educator’s decision; experts say that’s what leads to racial disparities. What seems disrespectful and threatening in one classroom can be entirely acceptable in another, depending on who’s listening and who’s speaking. That’s when racial and cultural differences between educators and students can come into play. Bias also plays a role.

[/QUOTE]

SOURCE: https://wordinblack.com/2025/02/black-students-are-punished-more-then-expected-to-succeed/

[QUOTE]Decades of research show that Black students are more likely to be punished for subjective offenses deemed as “defiant” or “disruptive” compared to their white peers who engage in similar actions.

“Unfortunately, teachers often interpret Black students’ behaviors more harshly due to implicit biases,” Scyster explains. “For example, Black boys are often labeled as ‘aggressive’ for normal childhood behaviors, while Black girls are frequently adultified and seen as ‘too mature’ for their age.”

In addition to bias, Scyster says systemic factors like the over-policing in Black schools and the use of zero-tolerance policies further exacerbate the problem. “Predominantly Black schools have more police officers but fewer counselors and support staff,” she adds. “That level of over-policing leads to over-discipline, which directly affects Black students learning outcomes.”[/QUOTE]

SOURCE: https://wordinblack.com/2025/04/black-boys-matter-why-are-they-disappearing-from-schools/

[QUOTE]The data doesn’t lie. According to the Department of Education, Black kids make up around 18% of preschool enrollment in the U.S., but nearly 48% of all preschool suspensions. Kirkland says that’s where the pattern and the pushout begin.

“We have evidence of disciplinary action and special education placements beginning as early as 2 years old,” Kirkland says. “We treat Black boys like they’re problems before they even know how to write their names.”

This hyper-surveillance — combined with implicit bias, adultification, and racial anxiety from teachers, aides, and school administrators — creates a cycle of exclusion. [b]Black male students are suspended and expelled at three to four times the rate of their white peers, often for subjective or vague offenses like “defiance” that don’t usually merit punishment in others[/b].

Schools that punish Black boys early and often, Kirkland says, are not neutral spaces, but sites of harm. Many Black boys are improperly funneled into special education programs not to support their learning but to manage their presence. And the psychological and social impact of educational mismanagement — damaged self-esteem, increased self-doubt, and frustration — can be deadly.

“Ten years ago, the suicide rate for Black boys aged 10 to 14 had jumped 144%,” Kirkland notes. “We’re talking about emotional and psychological death long before they ever drop out.”[/QUOTE]
[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics