Reply to CMC v Wesleyan

Forum Index » College and University Discussion

Reply to "CMC v Wesleyan"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]DS wants to double major in political science and integrated/integrative science. After touring CMC, we definitely loved the facilities and community, but felt that Wesleyan may be a stronger name for a kid interested in policy. We’d be full pay for both. Any personal experiences/suggestions? [/quote]

Both are excellent schools. CMC is a bit smaller and harder to get into (only 1200 undergrads versus Wesleyan's 3000 undergrads). Is your DC at senior or junior? Is this for RD or ED. If RD, I'd say apply to both and retour if admitted on admitted student day and select which felt like a better fit. If considering where to ED and they are happy with both, I'd absolutely suggest they ED to Wesleyan. ED to CMC is very difficult because the higher ED percentage is almost entirely derived by recruited athletes and other institutional priorities (including Questbridge/FGLI). Wesleyan also gives a bump for males which CMC does not, in case that's relevant.

[/quote]

great points. OP has a DS so the male bump and Wes being over double the size would give Wesleyan a clear advantage in ED. another thing OP should consider is that CMC has just invested in an experimental integrated science program that has just launched this month and is very new and untested. while the architecture of the building is a big hit, the substance doesn't yet seem fully solid. they've combined the sciences in a seemingly odd way and some students have been scratching their heads and [b]new class is limited from taking science outside CMC at the other 5C colleges because CMC really wants the class to commit to this new integrated science curriculum.[/b] but it seems very experimental and a bit risky if it's an area of interest.

that said, both great schools! Wes will be more better known on the east coast, CMC on the west coast. [/quote]
Is there any source for this? It seems completely antithetical to the Claremont colleges and kids there take science classes across the consortium a lot. When DD and I toured, a Pomona student was taking 3 mudd courses and a Pomona science course at the same time.[/quote]

My DD just did a virtual information session at CMC and the AO running it confirmed it. Starting with this year's class, CMC students going foward need to take it at Kravis (can't access Keck) unless they go through the channels of getting high level approval. The expectation is that all CMC students fulfill their science req'ts at CMCs new center, since they've invested so much into it.

CMC students can still take 5C classes outside of science, but they want to mandate science at Kravis now and they've pulled out of Keck. Pomona kids can still take classes anywhere, and CMC kids can still take non-science classes everywhere too. They are just trying to build commitment to CMC's new science thing while it's new. My DD was turned off because her favorite science is physics and CMCs's new model doesn't seem that impressive in that area.

It's weird. I'm not sure why they did this but I'm sure they have their reasons. [/quote]
I have a DD at Pomona and this is not correct. CMC students currently need approval to MAJOR at the other 5Cs, but you can take the intro course sequences at the other 5Cs, by getting a PERM approval like anyone else. It's always been true that CMC, even with Keck, has been unimpressive with physics, and your kid would be better served at Pomona and Mudd. Integrated sciences is an easy, light major so taking classes outside of it to get more exposure to (real) science is not that bad. I'd be more concerned that integrated science is too obsessed with computation over dedicated theory.[/quote]

I'm sure that's true at Pomona but I sat beside my DD while she attended the virtual info session this past month for CMC and this is what they said to us. She said that older students at CMC had one set of rules about taking science courses (the PERM thing), but new students (class of 2029 and 2030 and beyond) have different guidelines starting this Fall. She did say you could try to get an exception for niche cases but it did not appear to be as easy as a PERM as in the past or for other disciplines. My DD took notes so this part really stood out to us. I'm sure they will grant some exceptions in the margins, but it was clear they don't want to do this much (or at all) ideally and it sounded difficult.[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics