Reply to The Hidden Problem Killing U.S. Soccer: Are Tournaments to Blame?

Forum Index » Soccer

Reply to "The Hidden Problem Killing U.S. Soccer: Are Tournaments to Blame?"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]All of these arguments end up at the same place. Soccer in the US is the way it is because it's just not very popular compared with other mainstream sports. Every single one of the so called "problems" also exist in the popular sports but aren't "ruining" them. Excessive travel? Check. Big revenue tournaments? Check. As long as soccer doesn't generate the kind of revenue that football, baseball, basketball do, these dynamics will remain. [/quote]

Except those other sports aren’t compared to development results in other countries. Comparing the US development model for soccer to other countries shows how broken it is. There is no comparison for the NFL. There are only a few countries that play baseball and most of those the end goal is to get to MLB. Basketball is getting bigger outside of the US but still not many countries really care about it. Plus they all use drafts and don’t develop their own players.

Our professional teams are few, poor, and spread out too far. Our national organization is disorganized and doesn’t care to really get involved in the youth game for organization and oversight. The pay to play model doesn’t reward individual player development or incentivize coaches to push players to the highest level - it looks more to a cycle of recruiting and winning to keep getting paid. 
[/quote]
I agree but you are missing the point. It’s pay to play not because someone thought it would be a better development model, but because there isn’t another source to fund it because professional soccer doesn’t have enough money to fund it here because it’s not popular enough. If it were more popular there would be more money which would attract better coaches and athletes. Pay to play is a fine development model which could still turn out globally competitive players like it does in other sports here.[/quote]

You're saying the rest of the entire world has professional soccer funding youth soccer and that's why we're the only country where expensive pay-to-play issues exists?[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics