Reply to Please share your Asian/South Asian/Middle Eastern/North African Thanksgiving recipes!

Forum Index » Food, Cooking, and Restaurants

Reply to "Please share your Asian/South Asian/Middle Eastern/North African Thanksgiving recipes!"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]Well Thanksgiving food is going to be pretty much overwhelmingly English flavors, aka rosemary, thyme, cinnamon, nutmeg, etc. because that's what the pilgrims ate.

You can do your own thing on Thanksgiving and have ssambap for example, but it's not going to be Thanksgiving food.  just like you could celebrate Cinco de Mayo with beef lo mein or St Patricks Day with injera but it's not gonna really be the holiday.

But... make whatever you want.  If you like this food so much you should probably already have a list of go-to recipes from these places, so I'm not gonna post my go-tos.  Treat it like a normal Thursday if you're going this route. [/quote]

Literally none of the flavors you posted are English. Rosemary is mediterranean.  Thyme is mediterranean and North African.  Cinnamon is South Asian. Nutmeg is Asian.   The pilgrims did not eat that stuff. They ate what the native Americans ate.  Your eurocentric view of the world and history is so limited[/quote]

Actually these are the most traditional English flavors and seasonings.  The holiday was started by the pilgrims, and the dishes reflect it.

But by all means, no one will care at all if you dont do a Thanksgiving and put out some lo mein and go to town.  No one will care. Literally no one.  It just wont be a Thanksgiving feast.  But whatever.  Do you. [/quote]

Of course it’s a Thanksgiving feast if that’s how it’s designated. What’s with the provincial insistence that it’s your food or bust? I’ve never had oyster dressing or cornmeal dressing or green bean casserole but if someone tells me that’s their thanksgiving food I don’t tell them that it isn’t everyone I know eats corn muffins and Pepperidge farm stuffing. If someone serves me lo mein on thanksgiving then that’s Thanksgiving. Heck I have vegan friends who serve an elaborate pasta spread on thanksgiving. Are you going to tell them they don’t celebrate properly because they don’t eat turkey?[/quote]

It's not "my food or bust".  It's about the roots of a holiday.  As PPs point out, you serve certain types of food at certain holidays.  You dont serve beef bourignon to celebrate St Patrick's day, you serve corned beef and cabbage.  You serve a buche de noel on Christmas, not on Easter.  You serve potato pancakes at Hannukah, not on Cinco De Mayo.  It's really not that complicated.

I mean if you want to go rogue and throw a bunch of random sh** on the table, have at it.  But it aint the holiday.  And that's that. And no one will care regardless, unless they had the misfortune to be invited such a weird occasion. [/quote]

But many people do serve salmon rather than corned beef for St. Patrick’s Day. My oldest was in Ireland for the holiday and never saw corned beef on the menu. Some places had lamb. And Israelis often prefer jelly donuts to latkes. [/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics