Reply to Should coaches complain if refs make a mistake?

Forum Index » Soccer

Reply to "Should coaches complain if refs make a mistake?"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]The ref should not be telling players how to play.  Only enforce the rule and explain infractions.

If the GK put the ball on ground then the build out line rule is that the ball is in play.   Picking it back up doesn’t change that.

The rule on keeper possession is different than the rule on in play for build out rule. [/quote]

Correct if he puts it down then picks it back up thats technically the 2nd touch and the opposing team is free to break the build out line. [/quote]

Yes I am correct but read it again: when GK possesses from from field in play the ball is in play for buildout rule purpose when GK releases ball: throws, rolls, dribbles, sets it down, runs with it in his hands etc.   2nd touch has nothing to do with it.  On a goal kick the GK can place the ball and then their first touch of ball (causing movement) it is in play.   If GK kicks it a 2nd time the. 2 touch free kick rule (Law for the fellow refs) applies.   [/quote]

Correct on a goal kick however on a gk save technically its a simple two touch not 2 player so as its written if a gk simply bounces and catches it the build out wait is over. Its a horrible rule in general but its written even worse.[/quote]

Yes I correctly describe goal kick rule.   
On a GK save, the 2nd touch has nothing to do with anything.  The ball is put into play when GK possesses it and then plays it.    Putting it on the ground is putting it in play.  And build out line is released.  Picking it back up is meaningless.  The build out line only comes into play of the GK holds possession of ball and does not put into play.   At that age some leeway is clearly going to occur but the rule is what it is.  
It is a simple rule, only confusing to those who try to take advantage of it as something other than a pause to allow buildout. [/quote]

Incorrect , on a save the build out line is still enforced if  keeper puts it down and kicks thats 1 touch. once a second touch occurs by any player including the keeper touching it then and only then is the build out line released.[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics