Reply to Is your MCSL pool doing B meets this year?

Forum Index » Sports General Discussion

Reply to "Is your MCSL pool doing B meets this year?"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]A swimmers and B swimmers at our pool pay the same fee. In fact there are more B swimmers than A. I would be real pissed if only A swimmers got to attend meets. [/quote]

Should year round swimmers get a discount if asked not to join practices? The team spends far more time in practice than in meets.

There really shouldn’t be separate A teams & B teams. Those that qualify for A meets should be adjusted weekly based on current fastest times.[/quote]

Exactly.[/quote]

The thing is- if you don't do B meets, then most kids are not going to get a 'time' to get to be the 'current fastest time.'[/quote]
This will be DCs (age 9) first real swim team summer. I know there are time trials before the 1st meet, but is that what determines who is A team for the rest of the season, or do they time the kids at some point during each week of practices to see their progress/assess who should be in that weekend’s A meet?[/quote]

Every pool does this a little differently. You need to ask your swim team coach or A rep.[/quote]

Pools have the option of running Several Wednesday night time trials. No visiting team, this maximizing swim opportunities for your own team.  But this requires double the volunteers because you need to staff the entire meet.  I’m a stroke and turn official (for 10 years) and I hate it.  I stand in the sun every Saturday bored, unable to talk to anyone.  Now, I’m going to be asked to do every Wednesday  night too, even though my kids won’t be swimming Wednesday nights.  So. . . if you want your B meets, get S&T qualified.  I can’t tell you how many times I’ve had ppl decline that request “it’s not my thing”, “I don’t want to disqualify people.”  Yeah, not my thing either, I do it so the kids can swim, and we need reinforcements this summer if you want B meet swims.[/quote]

I don't understand this.  I understand why at an official meet, there need to be a bunch of officials.  But if you're just having kids swim to see who got faster since the time trial at the beginning of the season, why do you need officially qualified people?  Our coaches are clear that they can put whoever they want on the A meets.  Usually it's the fastest kids, but they'll take into account other things, like who is the most consistent.  [/quote]

Because you don’t want kids who can swim a fast breastroke with their toes turned inward illegally in the A meet.  They will get disqualified I. The A meet because they are doing the strike illegally.  [/quote]

Are you saying that the coaches don’t know who is swimming a legal vs illegal stroke? [/quote]

dp- I'm a stroke and turn judge.  I am responsible for watching 1/4 of the pool.  If I was responsible for watching the full pool I would miss a lot more illegality especially on turns etc.  The coaches are fully capable of being S & T- but they are also busy coaching, and doing all the other things they do.   Last summer we did a bunch of in pool 'meets.'  No officials, a coach timing  (all the lanes) and no stroke and turn judges.   The times were off significantly and lots of DQ's were missed.  Fine for what we were doing- but not a real summer in any sense of the word and certainly not a good or fair way to seed an A meet.  Another advantage to b meets with stroke and turn judges is that the coaches do get the DQ slips and can work with the child to correct what was wrong.  Otherwise bad habits get more and more ingrained.[/quote]

Yep. The the coaches can’t even be positioned correctly to make these calls for all of the lanes.  PP’s ignorance underscores the need for mor B meet parents to get certified so they actually know what officials do.[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics