Reply to Parents: Would you support a teacher strike if it means there is no DL?

Forum Index » DC Public and Public Charter Schools

Reply to "Parents: Would you support a teacher strike if it means there is no DL?"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]I would support a strike if the demand is full, effective vaccination of faculty and staff barring documented medical excuse. Every faculty/staff member would report to the middle school where they teach or that is part of their school’s feeder pattern the following Saturday for the first shot and three Saturdays later for the second. In-person school would start the following Monday. Teachers who have a medical excuse not to be vaxxed would teach DL for the students who cannot attend in person. Teachers who refuse to be vaxxed would be placed on unpaid leave.

Otherwise, no. I do not support a strike.

This will not happen, of course. [/quote]

I generally support the decisions of union members to participate in a strike. I'm not thrilled about the way WTU has conducted themselves _as an organization_ during all of this, but ultimately, given the history between the district and the union, I place more of the fault for the overall situation on DCPS _as an organization_ - not just for the way they have behaved during the pandemic, but going back for years during which school facilities slid into disrepair, teacher contracts took YEARS to negotiate, and pandemic recovery plans contained a lot of "just trust us" rather than hard numbers about what would be provided and when. In general, morally, I support labor over management. Every time.

I also support the above. I do not believe there should be philosophical vaccine exemptions for students or staff. Medical exemptions only and if you refuse to get the shot for anything other than medical reasons (documented by a physician), you are no longer eligible for your job. I personally think that vaccination for everything (including the flu shot, every year) should be mandatory for anyone working in schools (excepting the people with documented medical exemptions). I think it should be considered the same as any other qualification. Ditto healthcare, including home healthcare. I am extremely tired of this American mentality about vaccines that regular people working as lawyers and grocery store clerks and yoga instructors suddenly know enough about the science of vaccine development and epidemiology to competently decide whether something is safe. I'm pretty tired of the "everyone makes the best decision for themselves and their family" bs. Widespread public vaccination in line with CDC standards should be the requirement for education and healthcare. If you don't want a vaccine or don't want your kids vaccinated, you don't get to participate in those systems, period.[/quote]

I'm concerned that people think teacher vaccination will just end the DL nightmare, and they won't.  I'm hoping that teachers (and the WTU) will be good with vaccination + masking + distancing (through hybrid) + updated ventilation systems + all the other OSSE protocols.  However, I've heard teachers (and seen WTU twitter) state the following:
1)  vaccines aren't 100% effective (I'm not sure what the conclusion is on this point....)
2)  we still don't know if being vaccinated means you can't carry it, so all people that teachers live with also need to be vaccinated to make teachers feel comfortable.  This starts the thinking that teachers with kids will only be comfortable going to in-person learning when there is a childhood vaccine.
3)  kids can still get covid and DIE even with teachers vaccinated (again the argument seems to be that a childhood vaccine is necessary before in-person school can happen?)
4)  kids can still carry covid home so everyone they live with needs to be vaccinated too before they go into school at all 
5)  all school staff and their families need to be vaccinated before in-person learning can happen
6)  new variants mean the vaccines don't matter (I'm not sure this is supported by science, but that's not really the point)

I'm just saying that already there are multiple new ways of arguing for DL forever, even with teachers fully vaccinated.
[/quote]

Add this one: Even after all teachers are vaccinated, the DC covid rate must fall back to its summer Phase 2 level. However long that takes, and I'm not sure why but just because. [/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics