Reply to Pennsylvania Ave SE Crime and Potomac Gardens

Forum Index » Off-Topic

Reply to "Pennsylvania Ave SE Crime and Potomac Gardens"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous]Hi 8:59. I don't know if I can be preaching to the choir, because I don't think you agree with me at all. While I do agree with your first point, that these criminals (and they are) should be prosecuted, we part ways after that. I wish I had hours to make a well-reasoned response to your ANC rep's position, because I think it captures the way that many people feel, and I most certainly DO understand why they feel that way. I used to live on the corner of 14th and Tennessee, NE. While not exactly a neighbor, I probably know you, or at least know you a little bit from the MOTH list. I might know the victim. Hell, I could BE the victim someday, since I'm still at that Harris Teeter and Fragers all of the time. The Hill will always feel like home to my family. Trust me, I'm not immune to the same helpless anger you all feel at the way things are going down. But being angry doesn't absolve me of my obligation to try and make a difference, or at the very least, to refrain from obstructing others who want to.

Here's what I mean:

[quote=Anonymous]
[quote]We need the following:

1. Prosecute all attacks to the fullest extent of the law – the AUSA and Judges
should not water down charges or punishments. A violent crime needs to be
prosecuted, and not weaseled out of by our bureaucracy.

[b] I agree. [/b]

I get frustrated when I hear the talk about the offenders being `victims' and
how we need to do more to serve them. Well, life is tough all over, buddy. I had
a rough childhood, but it did not make me a criminal.

[b]This may be true. But your childhood is irrelevant. I had a "rough" childhood too, but I don't congratulate myself on not becoming a criminal. I recognize that my current success is the result of hard work plus a mixture of family support and, frankly, luck. Anyway, because some people escape the system without succumbing to criminality means that everyone will? Obviously not! We are all staring at the proof again and again. The problem is, we all just tell ourselves "it's not my problem" until random white women get punched up on the street, and then the focus isn't on the problem, but on the symptom. We thirst for justice, but forget about prevention. What a missed opportunity!

So YES, treat the symptoms. Incarcerate criminals, and try to rehabilitate them with counseling and life and job skills training. If rehabilitation leaves a bad taste in your mouth, OK. I can get past that. But what can any rational person have against [i]prevention[/i]? I don't propose investing in these communities or groups of individuals to apologize for what happened in the past. But in case you missed the neon signs: [u]the system is not working[/u]. Anything less than a systemic, layered approach to the issue just continues to cut the dandelion heads off. I believe it can be corrected so that fewer criminals are cultivated. I don't know all of the answers, but I hope you'll join me in looking for them with an open mind. To me, part of this starts with scrapping the TANF program that is failing families. On paper, it seems to be working, but I think the juvenile crimes tell a different story. This, coupled with early childhood education, universal preschool, and private institutions (like Martha's Table, for whom I volunteered for many years) who do things like tutor and influence, might change things. By the way, in no way do I think we should revert to the AFDC program of yesteryear. Instead, we need TANF plus, with the "plus" being healthcare (with great strides for kids already obviously happening) and childcare, plus additional life and parenting skills training being a required part.
[/b]

Does everyone forget about the actual victim of the crime? Our Government,
elected officials, non-profits and everyone else, need to speak up for the
victim's rights. We do this by ensuring that criminals are actually prosecuted,
locked up, and then get the help/therapy that they need while serving their
time. Maybe they should face the person they attacked too? Let them feel
remorse, and repent by serving their time and hearing how the victim feels (or
maybe not, since the criminal might get perverse pleasure from this).

[b]I don't think anyone forgets about the victims. I've thought about the constantly since hearing the news. I think this otherwise makes his first point over again. 
[/b]
2. Confidentiality laws regarding juveniles. When a juveniles commits a crime(s)
it is shrouded in secrecy to protect the youth. This confidentiality, I believe,
does much more harm than good, since the police, their teachers, neighbors, etc.
will have no knowledge that the child committed a crime. Even if the child has
committed and been caught for 100 crimes, it is still confidential. How can this
child get the services he needs if no one knows about it?

[b]Absolutely not. This ANC rep is angry. I understand. But I think his anger would be salved if the criminal justice system dealt with these juvenile offenders in a more meaningful way. The child can get the services he needs if the proper law enforcement knows about his record. The problem is that the criminal justice system is failing both the criminals and the victims. Unfortunately, the solution to this problem is not going to be publicizing a child's criminal history. Our problem is that the justice system is not doing enough. But let's not overreact and ask it to do too much. [/b]

3. If the offending juvenile lives in public housing, their family gets one
warning to get their child back on track. A second infraction and see my
proposal on Community Service below. If the juvenile commits a third act of
breaking the law, the family gets thrown out of public housing. Bad behavior
should never be rewarded with free or subsidized housing. I know that the DC
Housing Authority does not allow people who commit crimes to live in public
housing, but this needs to be strictly enforced down to the juvenile level.

[b]I don't think this would be necessary if the criminal justice system were corrected with respect to juvenile offenses. If we don't fix the system, and we do not simultaneously invest in Americans living in severe poverty in a meaningful way, this becomes a game of hot potato. Ultimately, the potato lands in somebody's lap. BTW, I hate to call this person on semantics, but I'm not sure anyone living in Potomac Gardens feels particularly rewarded. [/b]

4. Community Service: Commit a less than violent crime in the neighborhood, make
the child pay with a huge amount of community service (so every weekend for a
year is filled with labor, so no one has the energy to do anything but go home
and rest) and make them do part of it side by side with their parent(s). If my
Mom was next to me picking up litter, or painting over graffiti because of my
actions, it will make a very unpleasant experience at home afterward.

[b]I agree with community service and think he's onto something with requiring parents to participate. But the scope and level of it just illustrates how far away from reality this person is. Does he think these parents have 9-5 jobs and free weekends? You force mom to work and she has other children, too. So you take her and put her out there working even more with her child, who has committed a "less than violent crime." It might seem fair to you, it might even seem like as much as that mother deserves for, I don't know, being poor, "abusing the system," or whatever else. Let's abandon what we know about her situation and the desperation, and assume she's a really bad person who deserves it for raising such a "bad kid." What do you say to the other kids, when you worsen the situation of an absent, exhausted, angry, resentful, and desperate parent???? Who and what is left for these children? 
[/b]
5. Install street cameras that can record action that goes on. I believe that
most of our street cameras can only show real time and not record activities. If
no one is watching the monitor at the very moment something is happening then
the opportunity to hit `record' is lost forever. Some consider this an invasion
of privacy, but I feel that this will help identify criminals.

[b]Holy shit. [/b]

Write to our City Council, our Mayor Elect, our Attorney General and our Judges.
Let them know, we demand change in carrying out Juvenile Justice and fighting
crime.

[b]I agree with this. But let's be intelligent about the change we want!
[/b]
Neil Glick
ANC Commissioner 6B08[/quote]

[/quote]

Okay, so that's it. Since I attacked the thoughts of a person who was identified by name, it's fair enough to disclose mine. I'm Faye Black. Happy to stand behind my ramblings, but please forgive any typos or grammatical mistakes, since I'm trying to write this with some haste so I can get back to work.

[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics