Reply to Why do people hate new builds?

Forum Index » Real Estate

Reply to "Why do people hate new builds?"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]
All those things could be achieved by upzoning to allow new townhouses.  More tax revenues, younger families, greater demand to support retail.  Plus you would have more density that could support transit more kids within walking distance, and more housing closer in  for middle class people.    [/quote]

That's a different point, and you'd have people in older, smaller homes who also don't welcome new townhouses and greater density.  You're just dealing with Venn diagrams of disgruntlement about change.   [/quote]

To a considerable extent that is true. My issue is not with the folks in the older homes venting, but with the reactions of local govts. In the case of the townhomes, the local govts defer to the resistance to change.  In the case of the McMansions, they do not. Now to some extent that is because it is more difficult legally, to stop the McMansions, which are usually by right.   but I think it is also because of a bias towards the detached single family home. Bottom line, the combination of townhomes being illegal in such neighborhoods, and McMansions being legal, tends to bias the outcome towards much larger houses than a free market would deliver.  In that context its hard for me to be unsympathetic to folks complaining about large new builds, especially when the response to them is usually some variant on free market ideology ("you don"t earn enough, so suck it up")

[/quote]

So you want an asterisk next to every post defending new builds that indicates that new builds occur within the context of existing zoning laws, which reflect political judgments and restrict certain types of development, and are not the product of an unfettered free market.*

*OK - will this suffice?   [/quote]

Mostly I want folks defending new builds avoid A. Talking about the right to build what they want on their property, or similar free market rhetoric B. Implying that people with less money should "suck it up"  - basically if someone makes an aesthetic critique about new builds, respond on aesthetic grounds (as someone did above,  showing a poorly designed add on) rather than ad hominems about the SES of the person they are addressing C.  Don't use the existing demand/market for large new builds as evidence for preference for space, since it is very likely that in the absence of market restrictions there would be far more townhomes built in close in areas, esp those with good transit.   [/quote]

Well, we don't always get what we want - whether it's the type of housing we think should be more readily available or the terms of discourse on the internet.

If someone defends their right to build a house that is consistent with existing zoning laws, they aren't saying that it's the highest and best use of their property, but only a permissible one that may well enhance the value given the existing zoning.

Plenty of people have defending the aesthetics and quality of new builds, but those who dislike new builds typically respond by posting random pictures of the worst new builds to attack them.   [/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics