Reply to NYU Prof fired because his class was too hard

Forum Index » College and University Discussion

Reply to "NYU Prof fired because his class was too hard "

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]His nasty tone notwithstanding, I can't say I disagree with the substance of his farewell letter to students.

"I learned last week that I have been fired from my position in the chemistry department at NYU. I was not given a reason, but I assume that it involves the “petition” of last spring (which I have never been allowed to see or comment on).
I send you this information because I will no longer be able to make any changes to the current data for chemistry 225 (2021) and 226 (2022). ALL – repeat ALL - future administrative matters including, but not limited to, grade changes, regrades, resolution of INC grades, and letters of recommendation must be dealt with by the deans and/or the departmental leadership, Professors Tuckerman and Walters.
I send congratulations to those of you who did well, and an apology to those of you who cruised through this course with a relentless stream of 100’s. The apology comes because I didn’t stretch you, and thus deprived you of the chance to improve beyond an already formidable baseline. Keep it up!
This incident is far more important than it looks. Consider the effect on an untenured or clinical professor. If his or her career is at the mercy of disgruntled students and accommodating deans, how are they to teach real material and give real grades? Much the same can be said for departmental administrators who meet with students daily. Can they afford to be tough when necessary?
The chemistry department’s ability to meet its teaching responsibilities has been diminished. Indeed, the university’s reputation has already suffered.
Now a piece of unsolicited advice: It is very difficult to be self critical. It is hard to accept personal responsibility when we meet failure, as each of us will at some point, but it is an essential life skill you would be wise to develop.
Good luck to all of you.
mj"[/quote]

Is this for real?  Where did you get this letter?[/quote]

Yes, it's real. A colleague passed it along.[/quote]

This is pretty much why my father retired 15 years earlier than I thought he would. He loved teaching and I thought he might never retire. But over the decades of his career,  students became consumers who thought they bought the right to succeed when they paid their tuition.  Respect for expertise and knowledge has diminished and now there’s a frequent “you work for me” attitude instead.[/quote]

I'm a regular person so I have to keep developing, growing, showing value to the people who pay me money to work or I will be canned.  The concept of tenure seems utterly outdated and I have yet to hear of anything persuasive in favor of it.  Sounds like a contributor to ossification.

Students today pay far more for college than you or your father did.  Therefore, [b]the standards and expectations are going to increase[/b].  Sounds like your father did not understand that.  [/quote]

Whose standards, though? What you're saying is that tuition is a way of buying a grade. Some of us think it's how you pay someone to teach students.

This guy sounds like a major dick, but when college students are asking for "extra credit," it's pretty clear where the weakest link is. [/quote]

“Standards” means teachers should be able to communicate information effectively to the median in this class. I think that’s pretty obvious actually and telling that so many of you consider this buying a grade or some such nonesense.  This professor had terrible reviews for years and floated on his reputation as a researcher.   That sh** shouldn’t fly anymore.[/quote]

What?! The content of a semester of organic chemistry is fairly standardized. That way universities and grad schools can trust other institutions’ courses (and students can do ok on the mcat.) the idea that you would teach a stem class to the median regardless of how much the median sucked is patently absurd. [/quote]

Can he communicate the material so the average student understands? Yes or No? It’s not that hard. Lots of you folks don’t want clear lectures for the masses, like it gives you a leg up or something.[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics