Reply to MCEA and Jennifer Martin act like a bunch of lunatics at Council yesterday

Forum Index » Montgomery County Public Schools (MCPS)

Reply to "MCEA and Jennifer Martin act like a bunch of lunatics at Council yesterday"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]The Council's proclamation was hypocritical lip-service. "Y'all are great. Here's less money than you need."

MCEA can't strike. This was a reasonable balance.

(I'm not part of MCEA.)[/quote]

I agree. The USA is very anti-union, and this is why workers are treated so poorly. Being legally barred from striking goes against every working person's rights. Since they suffer under this ridiculous and unjust restriction that severely limits their power, MCEA and others are reduced to displays that make them look silly, when it reality it's the law that needs to change, not them. This is like the Jim Crow era, when Blacks were "free" in theory, but second-rate citizens in reality. This is the same situation for workers.

I am not a teacher or union member, but it's very sad to see how many Americans are just clueless about what unions gave them across the decades. Thanks to unions, you have weekends. Support your fellow worker and push for stronger unions. If you do, you might end up with longer parental leave, longer vacations, more affordable healthcare, more retirement.

[/quote]

Oh my goodness, are you mad? It is one thing for workers at a factory to strike. The company loses money and consumers can't get their goods. Oh well.

When public sector workers strike, especially at the local level, it causes widespread issues that impact entire communities. You might as well allow them to put guns to people's heads to demand salary increases.

Public sector unions are very different from private sector unions. [/quote]

Sure, that's why everybody just shrugged and said "oh well" when the freight railroad unions were about to strike.[/quote]

yeah, [b]that was very problematic, wasn't it?[/b] It would be even worse with local public sector unions which already have undue influence because they basically choose the elected officials that govern their agencies.[/quote]

Being problematic is the whole point of a strike, whether it's a private sector union or a public sector union. There is no point to a strike where nobody notices or cares that you're striking.

[/quote]

What happens if police and firefighters strike? People die. What happens if teachers strike? Kids don't get an education and at risk for a whole host of negative outcomes, including child neglect and abuse. That's fundamentally different than impacting shareholders' bottom line. The freight workers strike is a good example of a private sector strike that did have widespread impacts. How often do they strike? How much political power do those workers have? Not often, and not a lot. With public sector unions they are both powerful and strikes are deeply impactful. It literally is like holding a gun to people's heads.[/quote]

If truck drivers and freight workers decided to strike- the whole country as we know it would grind to a screeching halt. [/quote]

What happens if police and firefighters strike? People die. What happens if teachers strike? Kids don't get an education and at risk for a whole host of negative outcomes, including child neglect and abuse. That's fundamentally different than impacting shareholders' bottom line. [b]The freight workers strike is a good example of a private sector strike that did have widespread impacts. How often do they strike? How much political power do those workers have? Not often, and not a lot. [/b]With public sector unions they are both powerful and strikes are deeply impactful. It literally is like holding a gun to people's heads.[/quote]

It literally is not.

Now, if you're arguing that work in the public sector is more important than most work in the private sector - one contributes to society, the other primarily contributes to the shareholders' bottom line - I'll agree with you. All the more reason to prioritize working conditions for public-sector jobs. We need good people in those jobs.[/quote]

I'm a public sector worker and I vehemently disagree with the notion that public sector work is fundamentally more important. That's not what I argued and to suggest truck drivers and rail workers are doing unimportant or less important work is frankly offensive. I made a distinction between the political power of different types of workers, a distinction you conveniently ignored.[/quote]

Where does the political power come from?[/quote]

Clearly not from the ability to strike[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics