Reply to is grade deflation really hurting college admissions this year?

Forum Index » Private & Independent Schools

Reply to "is grade deflation really hurting college admissions this year? "

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]There is a reason why colleges and universities have regional admissions representatives - so they are familiar with all the local schools in a certain area.
They understand the difference between NCS, Sidwell, GDS and Whitman, Wilson, TJ, etc. 
Even large state schools have regional representatives. I don’t have a daughter at NCS. My kids go to the Potomac school but my feeling is that y’all are whining about nothing. Wait for all the regular decision results to come out and everyone will suddenly be oohing and aahing about the impressive admission results from NCS. This is a familiar pattern on here every year [/quote]

Newsflash not every college admissions staff person has a lot of experience. Smaller colleges who get few applicants from a particular school need all the help they can get understanding the curriculum. No AP, no SAT, no class rank, no honors makes it pretty hard. All you can offer is "see where prior graduates go? we should get in to your school"[/quote]

This is exactly right. There is lots of turnover in these regional college reps since it’s viewed as a starter job in admissions and with applicants up so much and from a broader array of schools and other institutional mandates to broaden schools fielding applicants, each rep has more schools to cover.

The reality is that some of the SLACs, and a number of the top 30 or so will know local DMV reputations when it comes to inflation/deflation etc but unless they actively try to refresh that knowledge every year, would logic not dictate that with test optional, institutional mandates at many colleges having shifted drastically in the last 5 years towards more diverse applicants, and over-stretched local admissions reps that a weighted 3.7 from NCS or GDS when compared to a 4.3 weighted from any other school at some point is a losing battle?

Admissions slots are basically fixed
Shifting institutional priorities at many schools
Applications keep going up to record levels
High turnover in local admissions reps
Less face time between high school counselors and local reps
And grade deflation at some of the NCS type schools

So what happens is that on the margins (and life is about the margins, right?) that 3.7 kid from NCS or GDS just won’t stack up against the 4.3 kid from elsewhere on just apples to apples.

This doesn’t mean the NCS or GDS kid isn’t going to a good school but it’s yet another reason why lists have “shifted down” in the perception of many parents who send there kids to these places

I’m not upset about it or grumbling but it’s just the facts as they are today. And I don’t see NCS changing this unless dozens of parents complain this year. And reality is that school will point to preparing kids for the future and their reputation with colllege reps but they can’t answer the question behind the question.

At GDS there is apparently one English teacher who refuses to give grades over a B+ to anyone in an upper level class. That’s stated upfront, a bunch of kids end up dropping out of the class etc but lots of kids stay because they feel they are getting college level seminar in that class.

One of my kids has many friends who left private after 8th and went to BCC or Jackson Reed and those who left say that just showing up for class at the other schools and doing care minimum gets you a 4.0. If you actually push hard and hustle, a 4.3-4.6 is easily doable.

[/quote]

So, in other words, it isn't "grade deflation" in private schools that is the problem. It's the grade inflation in public schools that is. [/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics