Reply to How do you compare academics when there’s no real data?

Forum Index » Private & Independent Schools

Reply to "How do you compare academics when there’s no real data?"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]It takes time and effort. When we toured for elementary, we often took discreet snapshots of the textbooks in use or the whiteboard.

Doing this caused us to drop more than one school from consideration -- because the literacy curriculum was Lucy Calkins, balanced literacy, whole language, 3-cueing crap. Note each of those schools was or is well regarded by many on DCUM.

Similarly, we looked for the math textbooks (We consider lack of printed math textbook to be a negative). We dug in online about the several curricula we saw. Most of those curricula were OK, but one had numerous reviews saying it was watered down / delayed. That dropped a school off our list.

Same approach also can be used with other aspects of the curricula. 
[/quote]

+1 for right approach to due diligence.  Need to do for each grade.  Was dismayed to learn too late that grade 5 no longer had textbooks except theology class - every other class was handouts or online via ipad/tablet.  Also look at strength of foreign language teachers - are they native speakers or a part-time parent with college level 201 Spanish at best.  And more than one foreign language offered to include Latin would be our preference.  Preference for traditional (non-common-core) teaching methodology as well such as Saxon Math.  If only there was a "classical" model that also had strong science offerings and prepared kids for IB Diploma and/or AP tests.[/quote]
If you're willing to get supplemental math outside of school, WIS ticks most of these boxes.  They start the IB curriculum in primary school and continue it all the way through.  And all foreign language speakers are most certainly native speakers!  The kids learn read a bit later than they do at other schools, but that's because there's a recognition that bilingual kids learn to read later, and why fight that when foreign language acquisition is the main goal for early years instruction anyway.[/quote]

I feel like WIS always gets some "bad at math" shade, but they have actually put a lot of effort into their math department trying to combat the rumor and are pretty solid in math now adays as well...[/quote]
I don't know that it's "bad at math."  More that its math program isn't as exceptional as its languages program.  And that seems perfectly reasonable to me![/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics