Reply to Common Lottery Algorithm

Forum Index » DC Public and Public Charter Schools

Reply to "Common Lottery Algorithm"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]
Child #1 has sibling preference but ranked school ABC at #3, and didn't get into their #1-2.
Child #2 has no preferences but ranked school ABC at #1.

Who gets the seat at school ABC?

What if child #2's lottery number is higher than child #1's?[/quote]

Child #1. Sibling preference trumps no preference every time.[/quote]

I second this.  100% according to the logic of stable match.  School ABC prefers Child #2 over #1 so this creates an equitable match for all parties involved.[/quote]

We were arguing this point yesterday, but as of yesterday, who is disputing this part of it?

The part we are now disputing is this:
Same scenario as above EXCEPT Child #2 DOES have sibling preference.  Who gets the spot then if both children have sibling preference but Child #1 ranked the school #3 and didn't get into 1-2, vs. Child #2 who ranked the school #1?

If you believe parent ranking has no effect beyond what order the computer tries to place you, you believe basically that at this point it's random.  Those of us saying parent ranking matters are saying that in THIS scenario, Child #2 will get the spot.  Hands down.  And random computer assigned lottery number does not impact anything at this point.[/quote]

If the students are equal in terms of preferences, the one with the better number will get the spot, no matter what ranking the parent put.[/quote]

Notable that of all the people saying this, none of you have provided a source yet for why this specific point is true for this DC Common Lottery.  Interesting, and frankly, makes every opinion that says parent ranking doesn't affect this scenario totally suspicious.[/quote]

LOL.  What are you trying to say?  That someone here is trying to throw everyone off so they can get a better chance in the lottery?

Either way, you should rank your schools in order of your [i]actual [/i]preferences.

The end.[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics