Reply to How much annual budget do you need to feel comfortable in retirement?

Forum Index » Money and Finances

Reply to "How much annual budget do you need to feel comfortable in retirement?"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]Depends on what style you are accustomed to.  I don't understand the point of these posts.  They aren't too valuable unless your question is what the minimum is for people to retire and what is needed for basic life, and addition of what budget can buy nicer things.  There is always a floor..  There are basic needs people have to meet to survive (shelter, food, healthcare, and for elderly - also some assistance).

But there is no ceiling to luxury spending.  People get mad when someone says how they need 7 figures passive income to enjoy themselves in retirement, but it can easily be spent by people with very high spending habits wanting luxury lifestyle, multiple homes, paying grandkids private schools and homes for the kids who aren't well off, travel, charity donations, pricey personal healthcare, etc.  Some also want to leave sizeable wealth to their descendants and that's their goal in retirement.  I think it would help to separate these goals that go beyond "comfortable in retirement" that tend to get blood boiling for majority of population that doesn't have 8 figure NW [/quote]

Mostly because we think you should be paying more in taxes.[/quote]

All of our income is taxed at over 50% when you include federal, state, fica, etc

Even cap gains are taxed at 22 fed and 7% state.

So nope we don't need to pay more taxes.  
I don't hide money anywhere or have a way to protect it from taxes.

[/quote]

I don’t see how anyone’s income could be taxed at more than 50%. I mean my take home is less than 50% of what I earn but that is bc it includes retirement contributions and health insurance. [/quote]

Because if you are earning $1.5M+ as W2 income, anything over ~$512K is taxed at 37-39%+, FICA is 7.5% (on lower amounts), medicare is 1.45%, state is ~10%.  Earn higher and even higher percentage is taxed at those rates.  So yes the "majority" is taxed at 45-50%+ quite easily.

[/quote]

That doesn’t add up, FICA is 6.2% up to $176,000 of income. Federal is 37% only after $626,000, income before that is taxed at lower rates. 10% is very high for a state tax rate, you should think about moving to a lower tax state. VA is 5.75%. I’d also be surprised if you didn’t have some income that’s not taxed, retirement contributions, health insurance premiums, etc.[/quote]

Yes the lower is taxed lower.  But if you have W2 income of well over 1M and any interest/dividend income is taxed as "income" you will have A LOT taxed at over 37% and your top state tax rate.  at that point your "health insurance premiums" and your "retirement contributions" are really nothing in comparison.  It's simple math.  Yes the lower 500K is taxed less, obviously I get that.  But my $1M+ in dividend/interest is also taxed as "income" along with my real income over ~$600K.

Point is, many of us with HHI are not "hiding from taxes" and certainly pay our fair share, we dont need to Pay more taxes.  [/quote]

Not sure why you think you don’t need to pay more in taxes.  You are very very wealthy if you are earning 1M in dividends and 1.5M in salary.  [/quote]

Because we are already paying more than 90-95% of people.  Happy to pay taxes, but when most is at 40-50%+, that is more than enough.  tax businesses and close tax loopholes, but don't tell those who actually pay taxes to "pay more".

[/quote]

You are wealthier than 90-95% of people. You should pay more. [/quote]

How do you not comprehend that we already are paying more than "most people" most of taxes are paid by the top 10%.   The solution is not to tax us more, you need to tax businesses instead.

I've paid more in "state taxes" in a year than you likely have made in your lifetime.  I don't get any more from my taxes than you do.  Happy to pay at current rates, but no need to pay more.

BTW, I've always voted D for president despite voting against my own "interests", because I give a shit about others.  But at some point, taxing the individuals more is not the solution Happy to pay my 40-50%+ on most of our income.  but not more

[/quote]

It’s already been pointed out that you are exaggerating how much you pay in taxes. In addition, you are in the top 1% so why aren’t you paying taxes to reflect that instead of the top 5-10%?  I’m starting to think you are making things up.  [/quote]

Not exaggerating.  Yes the first 500-600K is taxed less, but anything above that is at 37% federal along with medicare (1.8%) and state tax rate of 10%.  So damn near at 50%.  So sure 33% is taxed less, the other 67% is taxed approximately 50%.  Simple math.

[/quote]

Boo boo move then.[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics