Reply to My 2nd grader’s teacher intends to mask all year

Forum Index » Montgomery County Public Schools (MCPS)

Reply to "My 2nd grader’s teacher intends to mask all year"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]There is no clear evidence that masks impact children’s speech or social skills. It’s just something that gets repeated because anti-maskers need a justification. [/quote]

False.  There is PLENTIFUL research on the impact of masks on communication; and pre-existing research on the role of faces and learning social skills/emotions/language.  Beyond that, masks are an invasive intervention.  It's just not true that you can mandate any intervention as long as there is not "clear evidence" against it.  (Or whatever evidentiary standard you're using; it's a moving goal post.) Likewise claim that "blind kids learn to speak just fine, masks are not a problem!" is false.  It's well known that visually impaired kids need specialized instruction for acquiring language and social skills because of the missing nonverbal cues.

I'm not even going to post the research here because there's so much. Anyone who is interested can search on Google Scholar.   [/quote]

There are also millions of dead people from covid. So what's your point? Teachers should risk their lives and well being for your benefit?[/quote]

DP: The only point being made by OP and people who understand her point of view is that she has a valid reason to get her child switched to one of the other available classrooms. The does not harm the teacher in any way, shape, or form. This teacher can keep masking as she needs to do, and the child can have an adult model of speech in a different classroom whose facial expressions are fully available to her. [/quote]

What happens when the OP finds out that the masked teacher is actually the stronger teacher? Would she demand her child be moved back? Or is the lack of a mask simply more important than any other variable?[/quote]

Why are you setting up straw man arguments about things that didn't happen? You just want to keep arguing for the sake of arguing when there is an obvious and easy solution to OP's concern?[/quote]

It’s a valid question. If the OP is going to burden the administration and two teachers with a schedule change, then that action is simply stating that the mask is the hill to die on. It is *the* defining, important characteristic for the OP. Classroom environment, teaching methods, etc., are less important. [/quote]

I mean MCEA themselves lobbied for removing the mask mandate. They know it is a problem. This is not our f&cling imaginations.[/quote]

Removing a mandate simply means masks aren’t required. People can still opt to wear them. All this means is that MCEA supports choice, which includes the choice to wear one. [/quote]

You keep believing that[/quote]

Um… what else should I believe? Are you suggesting that MCEA is somehow anti-mask and doesn’t want teachers wearing them? Source?[/quote]. Have you ever considered looking at this issue outside of the pro-mask vs anti-mask binary so many posters here seem stuck on? That some of us can believe masks are sometimes necessary, and of course people should have the choice to wear them, but they have real downsides? I don't have the links, but I remember reading MCEA was talking about needing to end the mask mandate even during the omicron surge (of course they recommended waiting until the surge was over). I got the impression a lot of teachers were having a real hard time with them.[/quote]

But acknowledging downsides can be done while also acknowledging benefits. Hence, teachers and students have choice. My whole argument is that people currently have choice. Above, you acknowledge that “people should have the choice to wear them.” Therefore, I’m not sure why you are disagreeing with me.[/quote]

Ugh, I'm not going to rehash tis whole conversation for you. My point was that it's not invalid to be concerned about a teacher wearing a mask. They do impede communication. Folks (you?l) above seem to think that's not a valid reason to change classroom change. That's essentially saying any downsides are minimal, yet MCEA seemed to think they were significant enough to eliminate the mask mandate that we were being told was protecting the teachers from certain death.[/quote]

When did MCEA support eliminating the mandate? You "remember reading it somewhere" and that's gospel truth now?[/quote]

If you don't believe that MCEA supported removing the mask mandate, Google it. As for the exact date when they first expressed it, I recall reading it around January of this year. If you doubt that, I don't care.[/quote]

I do not believe you and I think you have the burden of proof here not me.

[/quote]

"After this story was published, MCEA amended its quote, which now states, Many educators are looking forward to relaxing the rules around masking. Others have concerns about what the change will mean for their own health and safety, or about the health and safety of vulnerable students and family members. Since the beginning of the pandemic, MCEA has consistently taken the position that we should follow the guidance of the CDC and state and local health officials."

https://www.mymcmedia.org/mcps-expected-to-vote-tuesday-afternoon-to-lift-mask-mandate/

"Schools should only mandate masks when COVID cases and hospitalizations are high, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention recommended Friday, in a shift that means most U.S. schools now have the agency’s OK to go without masks."

https://www.chalkbeat.org/2022/2/25/22951096/cdc-mask-mandates-schools-guidance[/quote]

[quote]In a statement to Bethesda Beat on Friday, prior to the school board’s vote on Tuesday, Jennifer Martin, president of the county’s teachers union, said the organization supports the decision.

“Since the beginning of the pandemic, MCEA has consistently taken the position that we should follow the guidance of the CDC and state and local health officials,” Martin said. “Given that the CDC, state, and county are relaxing masking protocols, the union agrees with the MCPS Board’s expected lifting of the mask mandate.”[/quote]

https://bethesdamagazine.com/2022/03/08/mcps-mask-mandate-ends-effective-immediately/[/quote]

Satisfied, PP? Are you going to at least acknowledge this...or are you just disappearing?[/quote]

Their head probably just exploded as they can't handle living in a world where non-Trumpers don't want to wear masks in perpetuity.[/quote]

A lesson for them I guess. If you're going to so definitively say "I don't believe you", at least do a simple Google search to make sure (particularly with such a softball topic where the good hits are right at the top).[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics