Reply to Sidwell College Admissions This Year

Forum Index » College and University Discussion

Reply to "Sidwell College Admissions This Year"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]I think the elephant in the room is that a good chunk of the very top students are “stranded”.  They are doing less well than the bottom 85% of the class.  Yield protected at likelies/matches and not into any SCEA or ED.  Sidwell needs an explicit strategy for these kids.  It’s not to late to advocate for this group imo.  No entitlement here at all.  I don’t think CCO gets the macro picture here.  These kids had safeties but safeties are not acting like safeties for this high performing group.  [/quote]

So, here's the thing...EVERY kid should have applied to a real safety school with rolling admission or EA (think UVM, Pitt, Penn State...maybe Wisconsin or Indiana)...it is hard for me to believe that very top students from SFS applied to these types of schools and did not get in.  More likely, they decided that University of Michigan or Northeastern was their "safety" ...but anyone who has been paying attention over the past few years knows that these schools have become VERY competitive (and unpredictable) over the past few years. If these students were depending on such schools to be their backups and are "stranded" right now, that does not seem to be the fault of the CCOs (unless the CCOs were giving very bad advice--which is hard for me to believe, as a parent of a "top student" at another Big 3)...

[/quote]

I know of at least 1 Sidwell NMSF deferred at Wisconsin so I take umbrage with your premise.   [/quote]

But being a NMSF says nothing about that student’s GPA or other attributes. It just means they had a good day on the PSAT. And it seems that Wisconsin was overwhelmed this year and that many of those deferrals may turn into acceptances. [/quote]

Well, they had a good day on the PSAT [b]AND[/b] a good day on the SAT. Plus high GPA, plus recs from school... Not at Sidwell, but have DC with high stats and NMF. So please, a bit of respect here [/quote]

The original post did not say NMF. It said NMSF, which is only triggered by the PSAT score. The reality is that many kids with NMSF qualifying scores don’t necessarily have the grades and other pieces that guarantee admission. I was not responding to any statment about a NMF, or denigrating any student’s other qualifications. The example given seemed to assume that merely being a NMSF should guarantee admission to Wisconsin. I don’t think that is true.  [/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics