Reply to Where are your kids Getting in?

Forum Index » College and University Discussion

Reply to "Where are your kids Getting in?"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]That’s just recalculating.  It is not the same thing as using the high school’s weighting.[/quote]

Exactly. They don’t use the high school weighting. They use their own.

[/quote]

[b]Well I have yet to see any student under a 4.0 get into UMCP this year on college confidential [/b]unless their weighted was above 4.0. I highly doubt the kids admitted here are smarter than these top schools with lower GPA averages. Something doesn’t add up here.

Looking at average GPA here:

UMCP 4.3

Penn 3.9
Brown 4.0
UC Berkeley 3.8
Harvard 4.1
UMich 3.8
MIT 4.1
Wisc 3.8
Notre Dame 4.0
BU 3.6
Georgetown 4.0
USC 3.7
Williams 4.0 
UVA 4.1

[/quote]
If you’re using College Confidential as your data source you’re doing it wrong.[/quote]

This data may come from Common Data Sets, though, which comes directly from the colleges.  What I've seen is publics like UNC Chapel Hill may have higher GPAs than any top private.  (UNC-CH also has higher GPAs than UVA and W&M, BTW.)  This may just mean those states have grade inflation at the high school level.[/quote]

Colleges are permitted to submit GPA data in their common data set as they see fit. Some reports contain unweighted, while others have weighted, recalculated, or no GPA data at all. [b]The UMCP average GPA is obviously weighted and is pretty worthless considering all of the MCPS kids with ridiculously inflated GPAs in the mix[/b].[/quote]

Oh good lord, why do people have such a hard time understanding this? If the colleges weren't recalculating GPAs to ensure they're comparing apples to apples - which they all do - then a school district should just change its grading system to a 6-point scale. Most kids would have a 5.0 or higher and could get in anywhere they applied![/quote]

I don't think you understand.  You can recalculate weight.  So yes, MCPS gives a whole point just for honors classes and a whole point for AP's.  They can recalculate that.  What they can not recalculate are the fact that everyone but remedial kids in MCPS take honors and AP's and that is not the same in other districts or privates.  And most importantly, they can not recalculate the games given the kids.  MCPS does not post number grades, just letter grades.  They have a system that no matter that an A+B will ALWAYS (ALWAYS!!) equal an A.  They also no longer make kids take final exams.  They also curve grades, they allow retakes of tests and don't combine the grades, just take the highest one.  They give participation points as extra credit as well.  These are things that UMCP can not recalculate because they do not know.

If Sally gets a 79.5 and an 89.5 and gets an A for her final grade. Not a B, not even an A-.  An A.  How do you differentiate another kid in the same school that got a 95 and a 98 for final grades, which also equals an A?  They look EXACTLY the same on paper.  There is no way to differentiate kids in MCPS.  And then when you have other counties and private school kids getting lower GPA's, they are in the first cuts.  It isn't like UMCP decides to take a few from every school.  That isn't how it works.  And if you think UMCP actually doesn't have 1 or even 2 rounds of non-holistic cuts to lower the number of apps before looking at anything else, I have a bridge to sell ya.    They received over 40K applications this year.  You think they did the "26 step process" on all of them?  Yeah right.  GPA is the first thing state schools look at.  Always have and always will.  [/quote]

This is exactly right about MCPS, but my son (in state), who goes to private high school and had a 4.12 GPA (low by MCPS standards) got into UMCP and was Banneker Key scholar.  A friend of his at a top MCPS high school with a 4.5 GPA and similar test scores got admitted to honors college but did not get Banneker Key.  So they must look at other things beyond the test scores and GPA data.[/quote]

Last, you are a snore. You are one person repeating the same stats about one kid in private, which ironically has weighted grades. There is no point [/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics