Reply to What's the difference between Amherst and Pomona?

Forum Index » College and University Discussion

Reply to "What's the difference between Amherst and Pomona?"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]I disagree and agree.

I agree the T25 universities have roughly the same outcomes (maybe take out the T5s which may have a boost). Very little difference btw a Top 10 and a school ranked 18.

I think for LACs, the window is smaller. Vassar won't get you the same outcomes as Pomona or Williams or CMC. I think the top LACs are WASP plus Bowdoin and CMC. Add Midd maybe for some athlete-finance pipeline or Harvey Mudd for engineering. Maybe there's 8 but not 10 and not another half dozen behind them.

I really only think about this from an investment POV. I wouldn't be paying full boat for a LAC ranked 15, like a Hamilton or a Wes. But if you get a great package from Mac or Grinnell, sure. [/quote]

Sort of maybe. There are eight SLACS (Amherst, Bowdoin, Carleton, Middlebury, Pomona, Swarthmore, Wellesley, and Williams) which average single digit rankings over the last 35 years of USNWR rankings. Two aren't mentioned too of which aren't mentioned much on this forum Wellesley and Carleton. Wellesley because of it being a Women's college and Carleton because of location in the Midwest. There is no real difference in them except for their wealth and location. They may have some different strengths but they are all universally excellent. CMC, Davidson, Vassar, W&L, and Wesleyan are close to this group as well with CMC floating around the top 10 for years with particular strengths in finance. Hamilton, Grinnell and Smith hang out with this group as well.

HMC gets a lot of play here and it is a great school for what is does but it isn't really a traditional SLAC and it's typically ranked in the 15-20 bracket.

So overall 8 equivalent schools followed 5-8 more schools with a shout out to HMC because of it's unique strengths.[/quote]
Carleton has 1-3/1-4 the endowment of WASP[/quote]

when we did accepted students days - the money difference was palpable. there are a lot of trade offs when going to a SLAC, but the opportunities that are available at a few of these schools is off the chart. Williams, especially. Also CMC, Pomona, and Bowdoin just seemed really full of programming outside the college. Travel, internships, summer stuff, winter stuff .. You can see where youre 90k is going

We didn't tour Amherst. [/quote]

I had a kid at Williams and have a kid at another NESCAC now. There is nothing available at Williams, Amherst, or Bowdoin that isn’t available at Hamilton, Middlebury, or even Colby. Same goes for Pomona and CMC. They all provide an incredible experience.[/quote]
Massive disagreement. Consistent availability and breadth of coursework for DD at Pomona in higher level courses is much more abundant than at lower tier lacs. Most of the economics-accounting/business/corporate finance/fintech coursework available at cmc is not taught at other schools including the PPE seminars (closest is Wesleyan with School of Social Science) and engineering, at Mudd, is available at very few LACs.

Williams, Swat, Bowdoin were other schools that had pretty specific and unique academic offerings. [/quote]

The offerings at Pomona are not different in any significant way that the offerings at other top schools and the amount spent on instruction is similar as well. Love your school but be real.[/quote]
I can’t imagine this to actually be true. The differences in resources between Swarthmore and Bryn Mawr were night and day. I don’t know much about Pomona, because I don’t like the west coast- but it has some multiple billion dollars in endowment and strong support on the west coast. There are definitely amazing things I’ve heard about the Claremont consortium. No one’s saying that Williams is washing Haverford, but I don’t agree that they’re the same experience, at all.[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics