Reply to DC's School Report Cards are up. Any surprises?

Forum Index » DC Public and Public Charter Schools

Reply to "DC's School Report Cards are up. Any surprises?"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]Look nobody on here cares about the bottom charters.  They are not the ones people DCUM are even considering, just like they don’t consider the bottom DCPS schools either.

It’s pretty pointless to make a sweeping statement about how one is overall better than the other and that can also be arguable.  No parent is going to be looking at that lens.  Instead, families on here are looking at what is the best school for their kid.  And that is school specific not a whole system.

[/quote]

We should all care about the bottom charters because they are serving children so poorly. With public funds comes public accountability. Millions is being spent on schools that accomplish little, and are passed along by the PCSB with extensions and discretion and "flexibility" to avoid political blowback and embarrassment, until they collapse of their own accord. Those students could be educated better, or at least not worse and more cost-effectively, at the many better-performing charters and DCPS, and the system as a whole would function better if funds were not devoted to propping up failing schools.

The fundamental concept of charter schools is that sustained low performance = closure. When charter schools do well, it's a "movement". When they do poorly, it's "let's not talk about it". Success has many fathers but failure is an orphan, as the saying goes.[/quote]

Ok, but a lot of those schools are tiny. Let's talk about schools like Roosevelt High School, a school that's been around for nearly 100 years, which has 1000 students, and which the city has spend a quarter *billion* dollars renovating, and still almost no one there is at grade level on anything. [/quote]

KIPP DC College Preparatory (charter) has just as many kids and also isn’t showing results.

The things is you mistakenly believe it’s about hating charters as a whole. It is the systemic issues they cause. Whether you want to believe it or not charters can find ways to kick students out after count day of course and do.

DCPS can never refuse kids not really ever kick them out.

And you have to be a fool to think renovations will cause a school to be successful. But this still doesn’t mean that these schools don’t deserve it, you obviously have never seen the horrible mice, roach, and cooling/heating issues -as well as an overall decrepit environment some of these SE schools especially have. [/quote]

DCPS does kick kids out of schools -- they just kick them back to their home schools or to special placements. Choice isn't just in the charters. Many DCPS families are choosing DCPS campuses they feel are better -- and their kids can and do get kicked out of those schools. Those aren't stats that anyone wants to talk about though.

What systemic issues are charters causing? If you live in Ward 7 and 8 and are zoned for a city school that has NEVER been successful in the way most on this board defines success, charters AND DCPS's out of boundary program are solving a systemic issue. Furthermore, even if you are not in those wards, if you want Montessori, language immersion, advanced curricula, you are most likely to get those opportunities in charters. DCPS could offer more of these but it hasn't yet.

Let's stop faulting parents for needing options and charters for giving options. Persistently low performing charters should close -- and they do. I'm not suggesting that the same should be true for DCPS but comparing the two groups and giving either a pass for persistent low performance is ridiculous. [/quote]

DCPS almost never expels kids, go look at the data. No school can kick out a student like a charter (who can create more specific rules) can.

Ah the old ‘what about W7/8’ (like you’ve ever taught or lived there). Yea, like the charters there are doing well. YES, they are doing better than the majority of the decrepit DCPS schools there. However, it’s sadly not that simple.

And who’s faulting parents? Just the city and its poor officials. I cannot expect all of us (parents) to advocate or do anything at all.
[/quote]

Is there a truly successful Ward 7/8 charter? My impression is that most charters there are pretty weak, and only better than the DCPS because they are able to do things to specifically attract higher income families. So like the Lee and Stokes EE schools might have slightly better test scores than nearby DCPS, but that's because they are attracting many of the higher income families in Wards 7/8 plus also getting some higher income families from elsewhere in the city who will take spots at these schools if they really want immersion or Montessori and got locked out of closer options.

It's just not a 1:1 comparison. If these charters were required to take the students who live within a high-poverty zone, they would have the same outcomes as the DCPS schools in Wards 7/8. Potentially worse because a lot of kids living in poverty or with very high needs will simply not be able to participate in an immersion curriculum or a Montessori classroom in a meaningful way.[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics