Reply to NYT: "Peak College Admissions Insanity"

Forum Index » College and University Discussion

Reply to "NYT: "Peak College Admissions Insanity""

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]The elite schools are basically a harry potter sorting hat for IB, Big Law etc.. and what they really are doing is creating a net work among the already rich/elite kids.  Middle class smart kids may get in but very few have the contacts and skills to net work themselves up that high.  The richer you are the less relevant your major needs to be[/quote]

I don’t agree with this. As a low income student, etc. who went to one of these schools, there have not been any barriers as far as ascending, etc. Frankly, once you’re in a company—and I’m talking about companies with established governing structures like public companies, companies that are close to IPOing, long-standing private companies, etc. your school/prior contacts are not going to tip the needle on mobility. It’s about showing impact, thinking outside of the box, being well-liked among your peers/leadership, and being able to make the case that you’re ready for the next job level.

No company is 100% a meritocracy, but a lot of companies try to get as close to this as possible. Also, in the hiring processes, especially for standard/non-exec employees (really anything below VPs) there are controls in place to stem nepotism. For example,  hiring processes with an emphasis on performance rather than who you know. A VP can refer someone for a role but if the hiring manager does not think they are a fit/they don’t perform well in the interview (s), or there just happens to be a better candidate, even if by a millimeter, they’re not getting hired. Also, I generally don’t observe VPs recommending candidates, especially at lower levels (i.e., roles/levels that do not report to VPs). They may recommend a peer, another potential VP, or someone within C-Suite. The pool for this levels of jobs (i.e., executive leadership) is quite low. Most people will never make it to this level irrespective of school, wealth, etc. [/quote]

+1 as a middle class kid who went to a top Ivy for undergrad then a top law school. I do agree that the rich elite kids did tend to stick together during college, and I was not and will never be part of whatever network they have. But I had no trouble breaking into Biglaw, which from my observation is based on merit - interviews, grades to get an offer. And quality of work to stay employed.

[/quote]

Yes it is difficult to hang with the rich kids at elite colleges.  I attended one 30+ years ago.  60% of students received no Financial aid (so think full pay at a school that is now 90K+).  Hard to truly be friends with kids who go on ski trips for winter break and spring break, to Mexico or to Europe with their friends when I was just focused on "I have $10 for my weekend spending---do I go out to dinner or do I go to a movie with friends.  Because I don't have enough for both".  I certainly wasn't going to concerts or other events that cost $$.  And for breaks, well first I had to work work work of I wouldn't' be able to afford the next semester. but certainly didn't have money for trips like that either.  
[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics