Reply to Trump/ICE deports a 4 year old girl (legal immigrant) who relies on daily nutrient transfusion to survive.

Forum Index » Political Discussion

Reply to "Trump/ICE deports a 4 year old girl (legal immigrant) who relies on daily nutrient transfusion to survive. "

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]Unfortunately the quality of journalism has substantially declined in the United States. What happened to investigative reporting? Where are all editors who vet reports before publishing to get the complete picture. Obviously the significant health issues appear to be a compelling case of why the little girl should stay in the United States.

However, I do not understand why so many reports just are relying on the family's attorney without getting all the information when reporting.  Of course a family's attorney is going to craft the narrative to be the most sympathetic.  This is what bugs me, people are just reacting without having all the information. And truly if they presented all the information I think most people would still believe that she should stay, but by not presenting ALL the information it affects people's perception and leads people to be skeptical and then that turns to becoming callous.

So if I am able to quickly piece this together, why aren't news reports able to do the same. Of course the story is more complicated than being reported.

It appears (short version): The parents applied via the CBP app and the father declared to boarder agents on July 31, 2023 he was in fear because cartel members had kidnapped him. They did not detain the family and were allowed in also based on the girl looking in poor health. It is unclear if they were admitted after claiming asylum and then not detained for humanitarian reasons. She has a short bowel and cannot take in nutrition without a very complex treatment called Total Parenteral Nutrition (TPN) which is not available in Mexico and her doctor confirmed she will die without it.

The girl spent over a year in first San Diego Children's hospital and later LA Childrens with Medi-Cal [CA version of medicaid funded by taxpayers ] paying for the care. She has appointments every 6 week now with LA Childrens hospital.  The father has a pending charge from when the girl was in San Diego due to raising his voice and causing some type of disturbance. Family gets notice in the beginning of May 2025 they are getting deported and encouraged to self-deport. Family's attorney files paperwork for humanitarian parole on May 14, 2025. Mother sets up a medical go-fund me on May 22 and has raised 36k.  DHS official via email to NBC news that reports about the family "actively being deported are FALSE.

This information was gathered from the following sources: 
Longer Version
LA Times Article Dated May 27, 2025
https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2025-05-27/deportation-trump-healthcare-immigration-humanitarian

1. The father is an uber Driver from Colombia and the mother, Deysi Vargas, works cleaning restaurants and is from the Mexican state of Oaxaca. The parents who are not married met in Cancun, where they were working. Just before S.G.V. was born, the couple moved to nearby Playa del Carmen so her husband could work as an Uber driver. The girl spent most of her life in a hospital in Playa del Carmen, Mexico, tethered to feeding tubes 24 hours a day. She has short bowel syndrome, a rare condition that prevents her body from completely absorbing the nutrients of regular food. Doctors told them to relocate to Mexico City to get better care.  It is not clear whether they moved her to the hospital in Mexico City.

2. The mother learned that the Biden administration had begun offering migrants appointments with border agents through a phone application called CBP One, so she signed up. Those let in received two-year protection from deportation and work permits.

3. They got an appointment on July 31, 2023. When they went to the boarder at Tijuana the father told agents that he had once been kidnapped by cartel members in Mexico who extorted money and threatened to kill him. They also looked at the girl, whose vulnerable condition was obvious.

4. They let them enter the country and the girl immediately went to Children's Hospital San Diego. At the hospital the father caused some type of disturbance which led to a pending charge and he is undergoing anger management classes (from NBC article posted below)

5. A year later, doctors referred her to Children’s Hospital Los Angeles, which has one of the top-ranked gastroenterology programs in the country.

6. Both of her parents worked, holding down odd jobs, and by September 2024, the family had settled in Bakersfield and S.G.V. was discharged from the hospital.

From Go Fund Me: https://www.gofundme.com/f/support-sofias-lifesaving-care
1. May 22 the mother sets up a Gofund listing the reason as medical and explains they need help with their situation without providing details and has raised $32,000+. I hope the family's lawyer is advising then how this could affect Medi-Cal eligibility.

From NBC News
1. Father has a charge pending in San Diego.  The girl's attorney there admitted the father does have a pending charge stemming from "a misunderstanding at the San Diego hospital when he raised his voice" when discussing his daughter's care in an area "where he did not understand he could not be loud."

Attorneys believe the charge will likely "be dismissed because he’s complying with the anger management classes the courts requested of him," they said. "This does not influence the legality of Deysi’s case."   It is unclear if this arrest set in motion a notice to deport or if the two year mark was approaching.

3. Family gets sent via email in April of 2025 a Department of Homeland Security terminating their parole and work authorization and told to self-deport.

2. A senior DHS official insisted to NBC News via email that reports about the family "actively being deported are FALSE. This family applied with USCIS for humanitarian parole on May 14, 2025, and the application is still being considered.”[/quote]

Great facts.  Thanks again [/quote]

I am just really amazed at how quickly people jump on the bandwagon. This isn't to say the little girl isn't deserving. I am amazed and am rooting for the mother because she has so much determination. She has been doing from birth (based on Facebook posts) everything to get the best treatment for her daughter. She does seem like a go getter organizing multiple fundraising opportunities for her daughter such as getting plane tickets donated from Mexico City to Tijuana, help with housing, etc. She is doing a fantastic job getting her case out to the media. She is clever and strategic and hopefully it works for them.

But I don't understand how 38 congressmen and woman can sign a letter to Department of Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem urging her to reconsider the termination of the family's legal status stating "We believe this family's situation clearly meets the need for humanitarian aid ." Other people have pointed out that requires the ability to show how the cost of treatment (including doctors’ fees, hospitalization fees, and all medical-related expenses) and documentation establishing how the cost of the medical treatment (both in the hospital and as an out-patient) and any other associated costs such as medical prescriptions, therapies, equipment and transportation will be covered, whether by insurance, personal funds or other means.

The girl spent 12 months at San Diego Children's Hospital. From July 31, 2023 (the day she legally entered the US) to August 2024. Medi-cal paid for that hospital stay. (Medical is name of medicare program in CA paid for by taxpayers). I can't even imagine how expensive a 365+ day hospital stay is in California.  There is a domestic violence case involving a minor against a man with her father's last name against a person with her mothers last name in April 2024. The girl's attorney said the father might get the charges dropped since he is enrolled in anger management classes. The mother needs to ditch the father but his claim of getting kidnapped by cartels is probably what allowed them to enter in the first place then when they saw how sick the girl was. Even if they did not believe the claim border patrol absolutely did not want to get stuck with the bill. So they have a history of immediately releasing anyone needing medical care if caught on the border by San Diego to San Diego hospitals. https://www.kpbs.org/news/border-immigration/2022/10/07/border-patrol-avoiding-medical-costs-by-releasing-injured-migrants-records-show

It seems like a better bet for the mom to stay is to say she is a victim of a crime. Maybe she qualifies for a U visa which is Violence Against Women Act (VAWA) which provides a pathway to stay for domestic violence sufferers. I hope she uses the go fund me money for a better attorney.

[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics