Reply to Math Placement Letters APS

Forum Index » VA Public Schools other than FCPS

Reply to "Math Placement Letters APS"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]Our math placement letter with a description of the various math classes for 6th grade is in parentvue. [/quote]
Can someone please share the cutoffs they're using for 6th grade placement?  [/quote]

There are 3 math classes for 6th grade this year: Math 6, Math 6 Advanced, and Pre-Algebra for 6th Graders.  The letter specifies "minimum score indicating a student might be ready for a 2-year compacted curriculum in grade 6."  My read is that this refers to Math 6 Advanced.   These minimum scores are:
Sol 5: 466+
CogAT Quantitative: 126+
CogAT Nonverbal: 126+
CogAT Composite: 126+
NWEA MAP Achievement Percentile: 90th+[/quote]126+ was the Cogat cutoff for pre-algebra for 6th graders last year.  It's strange they're using that for the cutoff for Math 6 Advanced.[/quote]

I don't think these are hard lines.  My child exceeded most of these scores and was placed in pre-algebra.  The letter also says: "Additional information that can be used to determine mathematics course placement includes: teacher recommendations based on classroom performance, parent recommendations, student interest and preference for mathematical challenge, and demonstrated aptitude through grades, portfolios, or classroom observations."  The one "hard line" I am aware of is the new state law that all students scoring in the top 25% of the 5th grade SOL be placed in an advanced math class in 6th grade.  But both Math 6 Advanced and Pre-Algebra could as advanced, for the state's purposes.  It will be interesting to see the number of students enrolled in each of these classes when APS enrollment data comes out in the fall.[/quote]
Can you share the SOL and MAP cutoffs for 6th grade pre-algebra this year?[/quote]

The placement letter only shares the cut offs listed above.[/quote]
It's interesting it's a black box between Math 6 Advanced vs Pre-algebra placement.  Last year they wanted a 550 SOL score for pre-algebra and that seemed to be a hard cutoff.[/quote]

Anyone receive this year's SOL cutoffs for Pre-Algebra in their letter? Or have other years to compare to besides last? Is it always around 550?[/quote]

My son is in high school and I THINK in years past they didn't even use the SOL?  It was the COGAT and the old math inventory they used to give them.  But I am not certain and could be wrong.

I can see the COGAT should be a main driver.  SOL scores can be very dependent on a teacher and how much they drill/review with them.  [/quote]
I strongly disagree that Cogat should be the main driver.  My kid took the test in 2nd or 3rd grade and a lot can happen in the interim between then and middle school that can really affect if they're ready for advanced math.  My older one never even took a full version of Cogat because of COVID.

Last year kids didn't have Cogat scores because of COVID, so APS used SOL plus MAP.  Kids had to be above 550 and above 236, respectively, to be placed in pre-algebra in 6th [/quote]

There needs to be some measure of a kid's raw cognitive ability, reasoning skills, quantitative abilities taken into account.  It's not all just showing you learned your math, which can be VERY coached and often is around here.  Maybe the Cogat isn't it, but I can see why they use it as a factor.

[/quote]
I'm not sure I agree.  If a kid who isn't super bright has prepped a ton to make sure they know what they need to know to get those scores and be ready for more advanced math, I suspect that they'd keep putting in the work to stay on that math track.

I'd be more worried about the smart but unfocused kid who didn't pay attention in 5th grade math enough to get a good score on the 5th grade SOL and who doesn't know enough math to get a good MAP score.  They obviously have holes in their understanding and need to practice those base skills more first.[/quote]

This is not how math works. No matter how hard you work most people hit a wall.  Even a lot of the kids put in pre algebra in 6th grade will hit a wall.  It should not be about prepping.[/quote]
Umm no.  This is not how school works in general.  No one will “hit a wall”.  There isn’t any sort of innate ability that can’t be overcome by working and studying hard.  That is ridiculous.  By the time kids get to highschool, if they don’t want to keep working/studying hard in math, they can stop.  Once they’ve taken four math classes, they don’t have to keep going.  So they can stop at ap calc and either graduate early or take classes they find more interesting.
I majored in engineering and applied math.  I used to tutor people all throughout highschool and college, and there is no “hitting a wall”.  It’s all just hard work.  Some people got it easier than others, but there isn’t any reason why you can’t work hard and study and get better to master material.  [/quote]

So your argument is innate cognitive ability does not matter in school and it’s all how hard a person works.

Interesting.[/quote]
Yes.  That’s the American dream.  Work hard and you’ll get where you want to be.  
We are talking about an honors math class here.  It may make sense for the initial sixth grade placement, but factoring in a iq test from second grade for which math class a kid takes in eighth grade or highschool or college is stupid.  [/quote]Let's also note that 2nd grader aren't particularly reliable test takers and it's only taken once.  It would be crazy to keep a 6th grader out of advanced math because of one test in 2nd grade when they have a interest in more challenging math and a track record of strong math scores.[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics