Reply to Is pride really worth losing your family?

Forum Index » Family Relationships

Reply to "Is pride really worth losing your family?"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]I’ve never understood why some people demand apologies from people. She’s not sorry. That’s why she’s not apologizing.   It’s that simple.  Maybe she doesn’t like you.

But I think you were wrong to cut off access to the grandkids.  Did she do anything to them? It’s too late for that now but I feel it’s always wrong to put kids in the middle.

I do not speak to my SIL for something that happened between us.  I would NEVER try to prevent my kids from having a relationship with their aunt.  I don’t speak bad of her to them.  They are teens now and can text her and visit her without me. [/quote]

DP. I'm sorry but you cannot seriously think that you go and insult your DIL, the MOTHER of your grandchildren and then have access to them. Who would be giving you that access? The insulted DIL or her husband, your DH, who is also put off that his mother insults his wife? At some point an adult must take responsibility. Sure, you can insult whomever you want, but this comes with consequences. Nobody owes you anything. Certainly not any access. It's strange to have to spell this out to another adult. [/quote]

So cut her off? But getting pissed that she doesn’t care suggests you aren’t serious about cutting her off and it was an empty threat. [/quote]
It’s very clear that it wasn’t the OP who “cut her off”, as you keep saying. There is no evidence of that. Some awful wife who forced her DH to cut off his mom wouldn’t be posting and introspective question such as “is pride really worth losing your family”. I think it’s really sad that you can’t relate to a scenario where, if someone disrespected you, your husband wouldn’t go to bat for you.  [/quote]

I presume they are a united front and OP isn't sending cards or photos of the kids to the MIL on the side. But deciding that the other party must apologize and then getting upset when they don't is stupid. OP and her husband and suffering from the consequences of their own decision. I guess MIL called their bluff. And it's not sad or anything b/c I don't know these people and don't give a rat's ass about any of them.[/quote]

The OP is not "upset". She is wondering why MIL has not reached out and apologized as a normal person would. She doesn't have experience (which is good) with personality disordered people, for whom this type of behavior is common and normal. They use silent treatment as a weapon. It's meant to make the party they hurt uncomfortable and ask for forgiveness. What is important here is that the OPs DH, who has been trained to respond to silent treatment by apologizing himself, has reached a point in his journey where he's able and willing to not do that any more. Hence from a practical point the MIL is cut off. People who don't have experience how silent treatment is meant to work do not understand any of this. And oftentimes this is exactly how the cut off happens in real life: the personality disordered person uses their silent treatment as a weapon and at some point it backfires. [/quote]

Look, if you would take her back and let her have a relationship with her grandkids if she just uttered some words then she's just not a terrible person. OP wants to punish her. That's it.[/quote]
I don’t think so. OP’s husband set a boundary with his mother: You behaved offensively to my wife. Our family won’t be seeing you unless you can apologize. So in the first place it’s OP’s DH who is the decision maker. What OP is trying to understand is why a parent/grandparent would not apologize in this situation. OP probably has healthier relationships and family and just can’t wrap her mind around why a parent/grandparent wouldn’t do this simple thing. OP probably doesn’t struggle to apologize when she’s wrong. She can’t imagine breaking relationships over something that seems simple. The mother/grandmother has issues. She’s not a healthy person and hasn’t had a good relationship with her son. The simple apology is not so simple to her. Whatever she struggles with, it’s more important for her to be right than have the relationship. And she probably knows that the apology is a step in changing expectations. She can’t or doesn’t want to change her behavior. [/quote]

None of this matters. If you use your kids as pawns in this game then it's just a game. If someone is so bad they have to be cut out of my life then I wouldn't let them around my kids, ever. [/quote]
One can genuinely apologize, take accountability, and make lasting repair with just her son. If these three things happened, it’s reasonable he would then integrate his wife and children back into the relationship, after such a period of time has passed that the son can trust reparation has occurred. [/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics