Reply to WASP? Is this a real thing, or recent construction?

Forum Index » College and University Discussion

Reply to "WASP? Is this a real thing, or recent construction?"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]What does bowdoin have/is doing that ranks it near Williams or Amherst? It seems really stagnant and uninteresting.[/quote]

Academics on par overall between the three, but Bowdoin has particular strength in:

Government (largest department, with strong connections on Capitol Hill)
Sciences (esp. Environmental and Oceanographic Sciences)
Soon: Computer Science/AI (Reed Hastings donated to fund a new program and expand faculty)

Not to mention reputation for highest QoL (facilities, forms, food) and student happiness which I think is the major reason why Bowdoin has been rising & winning cross-admits against W/A of late

Far from stagnant tbh
[/quote]
I don’t see how Bowdoin leads this. Other than Mamdani, there really haven’t been many Bowdoin alum in government (at the high level). Especially compared to Williams and Amherst. It has a pretty small computer science department. It’s nice that it spends a lot on making the experience good, but academically it appears very mediocre.[/quote]

Very confused what you mean by mediocre. I don’t think any of these schools are mediocre on an absolute or even relative basis.

Other than Mamdani and Pearson who graduated this century, there are numerous govt officials in Bowdoin’s history including ambassadors, senators, even POTUS. George Mitchell is one. The late Ed Lee was another.

Alumni list aside, the fact is that Bowdoin’s most popular major is Government and for that reason it does have a lot of student interest and success in that field. Your original comment was “near” so I don’t even have to make an argument for superiority here. [/quote]
It has student interest, but you're just describing an overcrowded major. Here confirms my suspicions that CS is overcrowded: [url]https://bowdoinorient.com/2024/12/06/as-student-enrollment-trends-and-liberal-arts-values-collide-faculty-disagree-over-how-to-respond/[/url]. Williams has a lot of current very important alumni in government: Lina Khan, Wahidullah Waissi, Philip Wilcox, Steven Fagin, Victoria Coates, Elsie Kanza, Don Beyer, and there's many more recent alum who have made world history (Notably Reza Pahlavi). I really don't think Bowdoin is anywhere near comparable to Williams in anything other than environmental science.[/quote]

So you are saying that Bowdoin is mediocre in Government because it is too popular a major? Overcrowded, when the average class size is <20? Curious. And those names of yours seem comparable to what Bowdoin has produced. Not going to get into a whole bake-off here on lists but I'll also give you Lawrence Lindsey, Christopher Hill, Thomas Pickering, and you can do your research for more. But if you really want to continue going through life believing Bowdoin is far inferior to Williams despite all available evidence showing otherwise, be my guest. This is a pretty pointless argument. Nobody is disagreeing that Williams is still the #1/2 LAC. But that gap is not enormous and contrary to remaining "stagnant", by admission stats, endowment AUM, and any other measure it's clear that Bowdoin has even closed some of the gap over the past ten years, which is exactly the opposite of stagnation.

Re the CS point: CS is getting (overly) popular at every school. And as the article states, the school is responding to increased demand by hiring more faculty...

I think you must be a parent and a particularly obsessed one at that. Cannot possibly be a Williams grad yourself - those I know are far more gracious and all of us who went to top-end LACs know our schools are very comparable.
[/quote]
The williams alum in government are much more known, prominent, and important. Compare the notable alumni pages.

Just because the average class size is <20, doesn't mean the government program isn't overcrowded. I love how you skipped over the faculty struggling with the CS workload due to lack of faculty and just made the easy point. It's frustrating trying to discuss with commenters like this because they choose not to get the point and bulldoze over the most important details. The gap is enormous. Bowdoin has a much worse yield, worse admitted students, and worse endowment performance. I understand the defensiveness for an alma mater, but this is just the reality. I think if you want a career in government, Bowdoin is going to serve you...fine, for a low level position, but you aren't seeing alum go off into the big careers like Williams and Amherst alum.[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics