Reply to National Merit Semifinalist for DMV Private Schools

Forum Index » Private & Independent Schools

Reply to "National Merit Semifinalist for DMV Private Schools"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]

[quote]The way this works is all so screwy. My kid missed the cutoff in DC by one point. He would be a NMSF if he went to school in VA or MD. Doesn't seem to make much sense. Oh well...[/quote]

Oh well indeed.  He did not make the cut with his DC cohort.  Everyone can find another cohort to make the cut with ... Alabama, Montana, or prison (GED)!!
What's so screwy about not making the bar in one's cohort?

Get a life folk.  Be grateful for your own unique gifts.[/quote]

It's not that he didn't make the cut in the DC cohort...for some random reason, the cutoff for DC is automatically the cutoff of the highest state. DC kids aren't compared to other DC kids. This year, they were compared to NJ kids, last year MD kids, etc. I don't understand why DC kids are held to this higher standard. It's not logical.[/quote]

Sure it is.

[b]Without this rule, the DC cut off would be even higher based on the relatively large number of extremely high scorers.[/b]

Tying DC to The highest state is giving DC a slight break.[/quote]
This is sarcasm, right?
But in case it is not, DC cut-off would have been much much lower without tying it to the highest state.[/quote]

No, it is true. If DC's segment were allocated by percentage of total graduating seniors in U.S. like the rest of the country, we would only have 16 NMSF, and the cut scores would be based on the top dozen or so test takers in DC. That would be a very high score. Using the highest state cut lets more DC kid qualify. DC usually has 30-40 when you use the current method, as opposed to the 16 we'd get under the state allocation method.[/quote]
I understand what you are saying but the problem is the cut-off is not based on the top performers of the state but on the OVERALL performance of the state.
So if DC was a state, it would be allocated about 16 NMSFs but the cut-off would be lower.[/quote]

That makes no sense. And it isn't correct. Why would the cut off be lower if only 16 were awarded?

The state by state qualifying score is set at whatever score will get them closest to having the right percentage of kids qualifying in each state based on the proportional rule, which usually works out to less than the top 1% of scores (the actual percentage varies year to year, and state to state). So DC's score would be set at whatever number was needed to only qualify ~16 students (including ties for the lowest of those). You seem to think the 16 kids who would have been the ones from whom the cut score was derived all would have scored lower than the current qualifying score -- which obviously isn't the case since more that 30 kids met the current qualifying score, ergo the top 16 of those kids likely had scores higher than the cut.[/quote]

where does the "16 students" come from?  DC's schools (public and private) have only 1600 students in grade 12?[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics