Reply to Now we know where Hogan stands

Forum Index » Montgomery County Public Schools (MCPS)

Reply to "Now we know where Hogan stands"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote]I think the PP was trying to claim that I'm a sociopath for... [b]believing in science[/b]? I'm not sure. S/he clearly doesn't understand sociopathy/psychopathy.

Really, though, in the context of a county as highly vaccinated as MoCo, and taking into account ALL the trade-offs in the cost-benefit analysis of schools being in-person (not solely COVID), yes, [b]I'm completely comfortable with children taking off their masks to eat lunch. Why wouldn't I be?[/b] (again, science, and all that)[/quote]

Of course the kids aren't the sociopaths - it's the adults telling them it's okay to remove masks and there is no risk that are.

How do you think these kids are getting infected if they're masked all day long?  You claim you follow science and took into account all the trade-offs a cost-benefit analysis?

Okay.  Show us.[/quote]

How are they getting infected?  [b]Probably from all the other things they do outside of school[/b].  If schools are as dangerous as you say, why hasn’t every single student in MCPS tested positive for COVID this past month?  I’ll wait.[/quote]

Every single student won't test positive - at least I hope not, unless MCPS does something really stupid such as not requiring masks at school.  Either way your point makes no sense.

Why didn't every single child get sick last year and the year before?  They were virtual.  The children only were infected if their parents infected them or they came into contact from playgrounds, etc.  The Alpha and Delta strains didn't affect children as much.

Why was there a much bigger 400% spike this year than last year and the year before?  The Omicron variant was much more transmissible than Delta, affected Children more than Alpha and Delta, and the children were in-person and without masks eating in school lunchrooms or catching it over the Winter Break with families.  The children had far more opportunity to intermingle with many children.

If you want to claim Omicron isn't dangerous, there were 6 deaths / day on a seven-day-average in Mongtomery County with 517 new cases yesterday.  The good news is that the spike is dropping, but we're not through the winter yet.

But is that your claim?  [b]There is no child-to-child transmission in lunchrooms?  There never is transmission in schools and it's all the fault of parents?[/b]  That's pretty insulting.[/quote]

Hardly.  My “claim” is that the transmission that occurs within school settings (cost) is well worth in-person school (benefit).  You’re reading so much into my post, it’s kind of frightening.[/quote]

My "cost" is the long-term effect of repeated covid infections on children's lungs, risk of health care losing even more seasoned medical professionals, the loss of teachers who quit the profession due to inflexible policies, the loss of life in the elderly or immunocompromised (both elderly and children), versus the "benefit" of providing daycare for parents?

It's kind of frightening that you don't consider these "cost" factors an issue?[/quote]

Anyone who reduces public education to daycare undermines any credibility they hope to have.  CHOP PolicyLab, AAP, UNICEF, NASEM *all* prioritize in-person education right now.  And you know better than them because...?[/quote]

..I follow real Doctors and medical science?  Not wannabees who want to be called Doctor because they are education specialists?[/quote]

Um.

Children's Hospital of Philadelphia
American Academy of Pediatrics
National Academies of Science, Engineering, and Medicine

And you know better than all of them.  Got it.[/quote]

Um, yeah.  Philadelphia?  That's your big support source?  You mean the city where the half the school district had to go virtual for a month because teachers were dropping like flies?

https://philadelphia.chalkbeat.org/2022/1/24/22899994/covid-cases-in-person-philadelphia-schools-teachers-principals-omicron-variant-drop

American Academy of Pediatrics?  The same AAP that warned 1M kids got sick with x2-x4 times the number of under 5 hospitalizations?  (Also see the quote from Susan Coffin, an infectious disease specialist at Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia aka CHOP in the article).

https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/why-omicron-is-putting-more-kids-in-the-hospital/
https://www.nbcnews.com/health/health-news/nearly-1-million-pediatric-covid-cases-reported-last-week-rcna12631

It seems as if they aren't consistent with their recommendations?

As far as covid-related in-person learning recommendations go, I couldn't even find what you're talking about from the National Academies of Science, Engineering, and Medicine other than some stale paper about isolation?[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics