Reply to Sharp Objects HBO

Forum Index » Entertainment and Pop Culture

Reply to "Sharp Objects HBO"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]*spoiler*

Yes, it was teeth in the floor. I also thought it was a very abrupt ending.

Questions:

So, did Adora know it was Amma doing the killings?  And is just going to go down for them?

[b]did she go down for the girls’ murders? It wasn’t clear whether it was for crimes against her own daughters or the whole shebang.  In any case, she pled not guilty. I don’t think she knew it was Amma, but no telling.[/b]

I understand how Amma was so messed up - with her mom having munchausens byproxy- it wouldn’t necessarily make someone a murder but for the purpose of the storyline one could argue it made Amma crazy/ dangerous.  But that doesn’t give any reason for her friends to be murderers too.

[b]I believe her friends were weak followers of Amma. They held the girls down while Amma did the actual killing.[/b]

Was her new friend at the end (the little black girl) shown in any of those quick post credits shots?

[b]The first shot was of the new friend being attacked against a chain link fence.[/b]

What was written on the new girls hands at dinner?

[b]Reminders like Call Mom, Text (someone), Read (book), Get Milk, etc. [/b]

I had such anxiety when Camille was sleeping with the boy - I knew the cops were on their way including Richard. Did that kill anyone else? I felt so so bad for him. 
[b]That was a really wrenching, well acted scene.[/b]

I’m so angry that Alan was clearly in on it or at least knew and didn’t do anything. That was obvious right?  Or am I stretching?[/quote]

[b]Blind eye. Refused to acknowledge the obvious.[/b][/quote]

I thought the stuff on her hand were messages for Camille. She flashed the hand and their eyes locked at dinner.

Spiked Milk was what Audora used at dinner to poison the girls.
Call mom I thought was in reference to her telling Camille to talk to her mom about Amma 
The hand thing was significant because there was a long moment from when Camille sees it and locks eyes with the girl

Was it Amma’s Handwriting?  I have so many unanswered ?s about that scene[/quote]

My take is that the new friend idolized Camille. This is what made Amma jealous and later kill her. The friend even mimicked writing on her body (or Camille saw the mundane written messages and thought she might be copying her), which made Camille silently freak out when she saw them. She didn’t want the girl to copy even her self destructive traits. [/quote]

+1
I think this too.  My theory is that Amma killed girls who took any of Adora's attention away from her - Natalie and Ann were both tutored by Adora.  And the new girl was highly thought of by Camille, so Amma is wildly jealous.

I could never read any of the writing on the hands or body, even when I would pause those scenes.  It was just too hard to make out - very frustrating.[/quote]

Oh now see I thought the glances at Mae (the new friend's) hand was that she had painted nails, and we remember how John Keene told Camille that someone had painted his sister's nails. So sort of a precursor to Amma killing her - she painted her nails like she had done with other friends. [/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics