Reply to Congrats to the GMU Admits!

Forum Index » College and University Discussion

Reply to "Congrats to the GMU Admits!"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]Congrats to those who got in!

It's a good school that unfortunately gets overlooked by many solely because it's too close to home.[/quote]

Exactly.  I’m sure other kids (from elsewhere) rule out universities that they live close to as well.  Kids from all over come to GMU, so it’s really just locals who pooh-pooh it due to proximity.[/quote]
I don't know. Well over half of students at GMU are from NoVA.[/quote]

False.[/quote]
[b]That's what SCHEV says.

From Fairfax County - 9,602 undergraduates
From Prince William County - 3,794 undergraduates
From Loudoun County - 3,368 undergraduates
From Arlington County - 748 undergraduates 
From Alexandria City - 451 undergraduates
From Fairfax City - 333 undergraduates
From Manassas City - 278 undergraduates 
From Masassas Park City - 182 undergraduates 
From Falls Church City - 68 undergraduates

27,519 undergraduates, so about 67% are from NoVA.[/quote][/b]

I don't see where SCHEV says that.[/quote]

+1
Why is it so hard to simply provide a link?[/quote]
https://research.schev.edu//enrollment/E12RA_Report.asp[/quote]

This link is from 2013.  And shows none of the above.  So I can only assume the above "information" was made up.  [/quote]

[b]The link does show what the PP said about numbers of students from Northern Va going to GMU.  Are you incapable of using the SCHEV data search?  [/quote][/b]

This link does not show what PP claims.  First, you can get to the figures for 2022 (instead of  2013) by clicking through at the top of the page.  That will show you that only the [b]total undergrad student population from Fairfax County is 9,6022, which is only 41.1 percent of the undergrad student body.  [/b].  Even if you went with the 2013 figures FF numbers would still be only 2% higher.  So PP is simply wrong claiming 67%.  [b]I knew it had to be wrong because I have a DS there. And I've taught there[/b].[/quote]

'T[b]is a pity you are so stupid and yet you actually taught at GMU.  You are a poor reflection of the quality of teachers there.[/quote][/b]

Right . . . you don't like stats.  Fairfax County has a large amount of students because they are the best in the state.  Same is true when you throw in the rest of the top nova schools.  No surprise there.  Berkeley and UCLA get most of their kids from the high scoring publics in California's metropolitan areas and few privates.  No surprise there either[/quote]
I would say it is more about proximity. [/quote]

No. It’s about caliber of student. Name any other high schools of the caliber of Fairfax anywhere else in the state. Name any s hook district like FCPS, Arlington, Asburn (on the rise) in any other part of the state.  There aren’t even pockets of great high schools or school districts in the rest of the Commonwealth[/quote]
huh? The top students in NoVA don't go to GMU. The acceptance rate is like 90%[/quote]

Not true. Median now has a 4.0 weighted gpa. Go look at SCHEV [/quote]
what is the average gpa coming out of NoVA high schools? I know at my kids' school, 4.0 would not be a "top student." With so much grade inflation these days, GPA can be tricky. Their Common Data set says for incoming freshman, 14% were in top 10% of class, and 40% were in top quarter. So about 2/3 of incoming freshman were outside the top 25% of their class.

Sorry, I was incorrect on acceptance rate. 91% for in-state, 92% for out of state. 90.2% for FCPS. [/quote]

For the 100th time, one cannot compare the acceptance rate of a public university to that of privates for a number of reasons but primarily because it is the job of the state high school counselors to steer their students to the best suited public universities. That is their job. This is one of the reasons that UVA’s in state acceptances appear high even though 75th percentile is a 4.47 gpa and a 35 ACT[/quote]
[b]I am a counselor in FCPS and this is not my job. At all. [/quote][/b]

Of course it is your job to steer to the best-suited schools.  You look at Naviance and SCHEV and lay it out for the parents and students.  You don't send in a B+ student to UVA.  You don't check off the most rigorous box for a B+ student.  You don't write a brilliant letter of recommendation for a B+ student.  That is your job.  https://scholarship.shu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=3974&context=dissertations[/quote]

DP.  You are very odd.  My B+ students apply wherever the hell they want.  They (and their parents) are able to use Naviance and SCHEV and see the stats for themselves - I certainly don't need to tell them where they do and don't have a chance.  It's so bizarre that you have such a mistaken idea of what high school counselors do.  [/quote]
Seriously! I'm the parent of FCPS high schoolers...I think pp *VASTLY* over estimates the amount of time these counselors actually have, lol. Maybe it is different in private schools but in public school that is not happening. [/quote]

[b]+1.  My kid's counselor barely has time to talk to us even on issues that need to be addressed, let alone nice-to-haves such as college![/quote][/b]

Our Langley counselor gave us plenty of time.  She covered SCHEV and pointed out how to work Naviance and showed us that it was definitely a "no go" from Langley for our UVA dreamer.  We actually saw her twice and had several phone conversations.  Also two parent/student assemblies on college admissions.  I don't know what box she checked but our kid definitely wasn't "most rigorous" quality.[/quote]

DP.  I'm a Langley parent too.  While our counselor also gave us plenty of time, he in no way told DC which colleges to apply to and which were a longshot, impossible, etc.  He simply made sure we had access to all the information necessary to make our own decisions.  He certainly never discouraged DC from applying to reach schools.  [/quote]
This was our experience too.[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics