Reply to The Case Against Adnan Syed

Forum Index » Entertainment and Pop Culture

Reply to "The Case Against Adnan Syed"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]For those that think he's guilty, what makes you think that? I started relistening to Serial and Undisclosed. I feel like there are others who are more likely to have done it (Mr S? Jay?) but am curious about why people think it was Adnan.[/quote]

+1 I completely think it was an unfair trial and I'm glad he's been released.

That said, from Serial and after listening to Rabia's podcast, I still think he's guilty bc he just can't reconstruct that day with a solid alibi. They kept saying "well it was a day like any other so how could he remember what exactly he was doing" when police questioned him weeks later. But it's also a day that he found out from police that his ex-gf was missing, so I would think that would make th day extraordinary and memorable. Just IMO

Also I'm the same age and this idea of leaning his car and call pH to Jay when he supposedly wasn't even a close friend -- just doesn't ring true as how things were back then at all.[/quote]

** typos - that should be "lending his car and cell phone to Jay"[/quote]

Agree. He's guilty.

-It's the most simple, straightforward explanation and motive
-Hae's last note to him and interviews/testimony with her friends indicated he was jealous and possessive in an unhealthy, not normal way.
-As much as Jay's story has changed with regard to specific times and locations, the key consistent points always remained that Adnan killed Hae and showed him the body and he helped bury it. 
-This same information he told to at least two separate people on separate occasions (Jen and Chris) who both reported he told them the method of death prior to it coming out in the news. 
-Cops may have fed or led Jay to some info, but I really doubt they fed him the location of the car. They could not find it until he found it (there were some theories about data showing cops running Hae's plates prior to that, but that was determined to be because they were querying if anything popped for it BECAUSE they were still looking for it, not because they had already found it. The location of the car was an empty lot behind row houses, not a very public area. It's unlikely he would know where it was otherwise.
-Adnan's personal recollection of his wearabouts that day are the most vague compared to everyone else. He also changed his story.
-The only other possible person it could have been is Jay and Jay did not have a motive, Adnan did.

That said, was there sufficient evidence to convict? No. But do I think he did it? Yes.
[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics