Reply to Homogeneity allows for more progressive policy. T/F?

Forum Index » Political Discussion

Reply to "Homogeneity allows for more progressive policy. T/F?"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]
While this is true to some degree, don't make assumptions.

I grew up with many Vietnamese children who were refugees. They came here in the mid/early 80s. Their parents were not educated. You have to be kidding.  That country was still recovering from colonization and war in the 80s.

I came here from a different Asian country. My parents are uneducated (finished ES), and can't speak English.  I have a degree and make six figures.  While not all of my siblings are as "successful" as I am, none of them acted out in class.

IMO, it's cultural.  Their is a deep respect for adults and teachers in many of the Asian cultures. Even if you don't like school, that cultural belief is so ingrained in your psyche that you wouldn't act out in class because it's "shameful".

The school I went to also had many African and Hispanic Americans, and real gang bangers. Some of the Vietnamese kids were also in " gangs", but they kept a low profile in school.  They may have ditched classes but they didn't act out in class.  The kids who acted out in class were mostly black kids.  IMO, they mimic their parents attitudes.  I saw these students get into fist fights with the teachers.

That's not to say that all Black students are like this, of course not. The school had a largish black population, and the majority of the students didn't act out in class. But the handful who did were always the black kids.  That's probably in part due to statistics, too.  But, this is just what I observed growing up surrounded by all different races.[/quote]
UMC Asian-American (first-generation), and this is entirely BS. If respect etc were such a big deal, why is there so much classism in Asia? Why are there entrenched rich/poor families and castes and classes in Asia? Because everyone always wants/needs someone else to put down. Asian-Americans have been leveraged as the "model minority" who are "better" than Black Americans but never truly equal to white Americans. At some point, Asian-Americans were complicit in this, though who can blame us for choosing not to experience the abuse that Black Americans do?

Most of the Black American people and families I know are among the most respectful and disciplined people I know. That's because I'm UMC...and to become a Black UMC American, you need to be at least 3x as disciplined as any other race or ethnicity. Poor Black kids act out because, like everyone else, if you are deprived of hope and stability, you act out. Not because they are culturally deficient.[/quote]
I was a poor kid who acted out. I am a felon. Many of my childhood friends became habitual criminals.

I promise that culture is far stronger than you believe. The ones who embraced the gangsta rap version of hip hop culture got trapped in a cycle of bad decisions. Other friends who were abused and neglected still had problems but if they rejected the thug lifestyle things generally worked out better over the long term.

Race doesn’t determine success as much as culture does. Race /= culture.[/quote]
I'm the first ^PP, and I agree with you.

Cultural influence, or subculture influence, has a huge impact on how you turn out.  That's why they say having a good peer group is so important.

The black kids who did not fall into the gangster culture did well for themselves, same for those Vietnamese immigrant students, same for any kid, even a white real American kid.

But to say that a Vietnmese immigrant child will fair better because their parents are more likely to be educated is BS.   Does this person not know what happened to an entire generation of Vietnamese people, especially the educated class?    The kids of that generation are the people I went to school with. Their parents were not educated, and neither were mine, and neither were any of my many aunts and uncles who immigrated here. Yet, most of us did not act out in class, even as not all of us went on to become "successful". 
[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics