Reply to Singapore/Dubai without Kids

Forum Index » Travel Discussion

Reply to "Singapore/Dubai without Kids"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]There are also A LOT of human rights violations in Dubai with respect to the (mostly) South Asian workers they bring over to do a lot of contruction and lower service jobs.  [/quote]

Have you been there?  Have you ever been to a labor camp?  Spoken to one or more workers? Or, are you basing this on carefully curated news reports?

You're correct though, there are abuses. Just as there are everywhere. Including here in the US. Just look at all the wage and labor violations here. Human rights violations, go to any inner city. Or southern rural area. Or western area.

The fact is, that while these conditions seem harsh to you, the laborer you are yearning protection for is far better off than he was living in a slum in Mumbai or Kolkata. By working in the ME, many laborers are then in a position to purchase property in their home countries. Send their children to school. Have hope.

Just because the abuses are highlighted here by the media doesn't mean that the reality is not substantially different.

And yes. I lived there. Was appalled and actually went to the labor camps. Met people. And paid a lot of my own personal money to help purchase food for them. Not that they were starving or even poorly fed. But being able to help 100 people by buying them rice or sugar for a month letting them save a bit more was satisfying. To me.

And to be clear, I was a banker. Not an aid worker. [/quote]

So you can mistreat people as long as it's a tad better than where they came from? Even when Dubai clearly has the funds to not treat them so poorly? And I can't comment on a thread specifically about Dubai without also mentioning all the other ills in the world? Got it. Didn't realize that was the bar. ?[/quote]

If this is your standard, where is an acceptable location?  Show me one place that I cannot point out human rights abuses an ill treatment. So I guess you're left with nowhere.

Face it. You like being pompous and holier-than-thou and probably do nothing other than preach. [/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics